You can be a superstar or a super sub and be adored or ignored. An athlete’s star power or popularity often has little to do with his skills or even his character. Such is the fickle nature of American sports fans. Which stars have come up short when it comes to getting their proper respect? NBCSports.com takes a look at some of the most under-appreciated athletes, then and now.

Click here to see our readers' picks.

MORE FROM OTHER SPORTS

Other sports Section Front

Choosing poker over college pays off for Cada   Video: Haye says he's no Muhammad Ali, yet Assault charge dropped against wrestler Kurt Angle Horse of the Year Azeri brings $2.25 million R.I. girls’ high school soccer game ends in brawl Chestnut wins meatball-eating competition in Vegas   Slideshow: Top 20 fighters in the world Slideshow: Ugliest uniforms in sports World of Adventure Sports on NBC Championship Off-Road Racing on NBC Other sports Section Front   Add Other sports headlines to your news reader: