Skip navigation

Yankees suffer their
worst loss ever: 22-0

Debacle against Indians reduces
N.Y. lead over Boston to 3 1/2 games

Image: Javier Vazquez
Bill Kostroun / AP
Yankees pitcher Javier Vazquez rubs up a new ball after the Indians' Travis Hafner hit a bases-clearing triple Tuesday. Vazquez (13-8) gave up six runs in 1 1/3 innings. The Indians shelled Yankees pitching for 22 runs.
Video: Baseball from NBC Sports
Damon: "We'll have to wait and see"
Nov. 24: Free agent Johnny Damon says that he'd like to stay with the Yankees, but he's willing to listen to any team and will have to wait and see how it shakes out.

updated 6:50 p.m. ET Sept. 1, 2004

NEW YORK - The hits and runs kept coming, spinning by on the scoreboard as fast as symbols on a slot machine.

It wasn’t just a rout, it was an epic defeat, the most one-sided in the 101-year history of the New York Yankees. Cleveland’s 22-0 victory Tuesday night matched the biggest post-1900 shutout margin in the major leagues, Pittsburgh’s win at the Chicago Cubs on Sept. 16, 1975.

“There’s a certain element of embarrassment, no question,” Yankees manager Joe Torre said. “It’s hard to handle. It’s something you have to bounce back from.”

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

New York’s $180 million collection of All-Stars led the AL East by 10½ games on the morning of Aug. 16 and was expected to romp to its seventh straight division title. Now the Yankees are just 3½ games ahead of Boston for the first time since the morning of June

19. The Red Sox beat Anaheim 10-7 on Tuesday night for their 19th win in 23 games.

Omar Vizquel had six hits to tie the American League record for a nine-inning game, and Javier Vazquez (13-8) was knocked out after 1 1-3 innings, matching the shortest outing of his major league career.


Cleveland set a record for runs by an opponent in a Yankees’ home game, finishing two shy of the most ever against the proud franchise, winner of a record 26 World Series titles.

After watching his original hometown team make the Yankees resemble hapless Little Leaguers, New York owner George Steinbrenner refused to answer questions as he departed the ballpark. On Wednesday, he issued a statement.

“Sure, we got punished badly last night, but winners never quit and quitters never win,” Steinbrenner said. “New Yorkers never quit, and we reflect the spirit of New York.”

Cleveland, which had lost eight straight games at Yankee Stadium since June 2001, scored three runs in each of the first three innings, then added six in the fifth. Jody Gerut and Victor Martinez hit three-run homers off Esteban Loaiza in the ninth.

“It’s one game,” the Yankees’ Alex Rodriguez said. “If we win 22-0, we’re not going to get credit for three victories.”

New York had never lost by more than 18 runs, falling 24-6 at Cleveland on July 29, 1928, and 19-1 at home against Detroit on June 17, 1925.

“They’ve got to come out here with a different attitude,” Posada said of his teammates. “We can’t worry about the Red Sox. We’ve got to worry about us, what we can do here.”

Cleveland had season highs for runs and hits (22) and set a team record for largest shutout victory. Jake Westbrook (12-6) improved to 6-1 in his last nine starts, allowing five hits in seven innings. Jeremy Guthrie finished with hitless relief, extending the scoreless streak by Cleveland pitchers to 21 innings.

Vazquez, his head bowed and wiping sweat off his face as he walked off to boos, gave up six runs. The Indians scored seven off Tanyon Sturtze and three against C.J. Nitkowski.

“I thought I had good stuff today coming into the game,” said Vazquez, 2-4 in eight starts following New York losses.

His stuff was good for Cleveland, which moved back over .500 at 67-66 and remained seven games behind AL Central-leading Minnesota. By the fifth, every Indians batter had scored and the top eight in the order all had RBIs.

“Our goal is to make a final run at this thing,” Indians manager Eric Wedge said.

Travis Hafner hit a three-run triple in the first, Coco Crisp homered and drove in three runs, and Vizquel and Martinez had four RBIs each. Vizquel had a chance for a seventh hit, but flied out in the ninth.

“Every at-bat, you try to do what fits the situation,” he said. “I just happened to put the ball in play every time.”

New York, booed early and often by the crowd of 51,777, has lost five straight home games for the first time since May 2003. Its season is beginning to resemble 1978 in reverse. The Yankees dropped to fourth place and trailed the Red Sox by 14 games after play on July 19 that year, then rebounded to win the AL East in a one-game playoff.

The largest lead held by a team that failed to finish first was 11 games by the 1995 California Angels, according to Elias.

“Your job is to be negative, is to look at the dark side,” Torre told reporters. “In this clubhouse, we don’t do that.”

Rodriguez predicted a turnaround Wednesday night, when Orlando Hernandez (5-0) faces Cleveland’s C.C. Sabathia (10-8).

“We’re going to have a great September,” Rodriguez said, “starting tomorrow.”

Notes: Cleveland has won consecutive shutouts for the first time since April 14-15, 1991, in Boston. ... Jorge Orta had been the last Cleveland player with six hits in a nine-inning game, on June 15, 1980, against Minnesota. ... Vazquez also lasted 1 1-3 innings on April 14, 1998, for Montreal against Milwaukee.

© 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Sponsored links