Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Clinton: Syria leader's 'rule by murder' must end

Heat hit big, but aren’t only free agency winners

Bulls, Mavs, Celtics and Knicks earn high marks on offseason report card

Image: LeBron James, Dwyane Wade, Chris BoshGetty Images Contributor
The Miami Heat scooped the top three free agents available by re-signing Dwyane Wade, middle, and adding LeBron James, left, and Chris Bosh, writes NBCSports.com contributor Ira Winderman.

Ira Winderman
When it comes to the NBA Draft "report cards," there is plenty to debate about the grading system.

There simply are too many unknowns, not only translating the college game into pro potential, but also evaluating players just a year removed from their high-school proms.

But grading free agency and offseason personnel moves is not nearly as much of an abstract. For the most part, the players signed or lost are known quantities. There is a basis for comparison.

So after happily handing off grading of the NBA Draft to others, and now removing the rookie part of the equation, we get out the marking pens and try to make sense of what has transpired thus far, appreciating that the subtleties of one additional move could alter the grade-point average.

Grade: A-plus

Slideshow
Image: LeBron James
  Are you a witness?
A look at the highs and lows of LeBron James' career.

NBCSports.com

Miami Heat: Forget how it came together. Consider rather that it came together, one-quarter of the U.S. Olympic team now under one roof.

This is not only a stand-alone offseason, but the greatest haul in free-agency history.

This is not just the Lakers landing Shaquille O'Neal from the Magic. This is not just Grant Hill leaving the Pistons for the Magic.

This is going to the top of the free-agent list and putting check marks next to the first three names.

A little humility eventually would help. But for now, it's the humidity that rules.

Grade: A

Chicago Bulls: Plan B left Chicago with far more than a passing grade.

A team that desperately needed a post presence got one in Carlos Boozer. A team that lacked outside shooting landed the 3-point artistry of Kyle Korver. A team that needed to replace the defensive grit of Kirk Hinrich got the defensive motor of Ronnie Brewer. Heck, there now is even a competent backup point guard in place behind Derrick Rose in C.J. Watson.

Slideshow
Image: Dwyane Wade
  Too hot to handle
A look at the highs and lows of Heat guard Dwyane Wade's career.

more photos

Oh, it would have been nice not to have lost Ben Gordon a year ago, not to have sacrificed Hinrich in the name of cap space, and not to have seen Brad Miller walk. But from the coaching seat to the depth of the roster, the Bulls came out just fine for a team that failed to land James, Bosh or Wade.

Grade: A-minus

Dallas Mavericks: This is what we don't get about the Mavericks: At every trade deadline, during every offseason, Dallas comes out a huge winner. Seemingly always.

So why aren't there more NBA finals appearances? Why isn't there anything tangible from the continued heists?

Not only was Dirk Nowitzki retained, and retained below the maximum, but the Mavericks heisted Tyson Chandler from the Bobcats and retained Brendan Haywood in case they opt to go to an all-center lineup.

In July and mid-February, Mark Cuban continues to top the polls.

Grade: B-plus

Slideshow
CHAMPIONSHIP BANNERS
  Title town
A look back at the 17 championships the Boston Celtics have won.

NBCSports.com

Boston Celtics: The most significant gain for Boston was not in free agency, but in the return of coach Doc Rivers. The Celtics remain in good hands.

Boston accomplished all it needed to accomplish by retaining Paul Pierce and Ray Allen. No matter what the regular season brings, the playoffs again will deliver the type of fear associated with an experienced roster.

Getting Jermaine O'Neal to fill in while Kendrick Perkins rehabs was a master stroke. And with Nate Robinson back, the legend of Donkey and Shrek continues.

New York Knicks: No, the haul is not overwhelming, certainly nothing along the order of Wade, James or Bosh.

But the Knicks set out to offer change, dramatic change, and did just that by going into instant-attack mode in landing Amare Stoudemire and then upgrading at point guard with Raymond Felton (albeit as one of the league's few teams that could call Felton an upgrade).

And while David Lee was sacrificed in a sign-and-trade with the Warriors, the depth of talent landed from Golden State will go a long way on a roster that previously only listed the depths of despair.

Orlando Magic: They're playing for keeps, when they could have folded to the ridiculous front-loaded offer sheet the Bulls extended to J.J. Redick. It was the correct and brave move for a team moving into a new arena.

Quentin Richardson also will help, although we're not as sold on Chris Duhon.

San Antonio Spurs: Tiago Splitter. Remember that name. Gregg Popovich and R.C. Buford will make you remember that name.

And then they'll laugh that arrogant little laugh, the one they laughed after nabbing Manu Ginobili and Tony Parker. For the rest of the league: hoodwinked again.

Grade: B

Phoenix Suns: The sting of the loss of Amare Stoudemire would have been far more severe to almost any other organization.

Slideshow
Image: Kobe Bryant
  Main attraction
A look at the highs and lows of Lakers guard Kobe Bryant's career.
Instead, Channing Frye was retained and Hedo Turkoglu, Hakim Warrick and Josh Childress were added.

All in all, it was quite a feat for an organization operating without a general manager.

Utah Jazz: Just like the Suns made a nice recovery after the loss of Amare Stoudemire, so, too, did the Jazz from the loss of Carlos Boozer.

With Al Jefferson, there is a post presence to replace Boozer. With Raja Bell, there is a perimeter option to replace Wesley Matthews. Now there needs to be a 3-point shooter to replace Kyle Korver. It is not out of the realm that Kevin O'Connor gets that done, too.

Houston Rockets: Daryl Morey tried to make his splash with Chris Bosh and apparently made a pretty compelling pitch. But the lack of cap space was the Rockets' undoing.

Still, a good team that is getting Yao Ming back also bolstered its power rotation with the addition of Brad Miller and the re-signing of Luis Scola. Retaining Kyle Lowry was a bonus.

Special feature
History of the Lakers
Timeline: A year-by-year look at the storied basketball franchise, winner of 16 NBA championships.

NBCSports.com

Los Angeles Lakers: Derek Fisher was retained at close to the amount Jerry Buss had budgeted and Steve Blake arrived as an upgrade on free-agent casualty Jordan Farmar.

A championship core got slightly better. Nothing wrong with that.

As with the Celtics, getting the coach to stay made free agency secondary.

Milwaukee Bucks: A team of limited means made limited upgrades.

Retaining John Salmons was a positive step, as was the addition of Corey Maggette. And Keyon Dooling will do just fine in place of Luke Ridnour. Drew Gooden? We're not as sold on that one.

With Andrew Bogut back, the Bucks will remain in playoff contention. A typically solid John Hammond offseason.

Grade: B-minus

Memphis Grizzlies: We know we should feel better about Rudy Gay staying, considering there was considerable thought that he would attract a make-management-think-twice offer sheet.

But the fact that the Grizzlies immediately tossed max money at Gay made it seem like a surrender to the process. Yes, Tony Allen can defend, but so could a healthy Ronnie Brewer, who was cast aside.

Basically, just more running in place.

Portland Trail Blazers: Sure the Blazers overpaid for Wesley Matthews. But there is something to be said about scoring guards out of Marquette. And while the loss of Martell Webster offset some of the gain, Portland did a decent job of holding its ground.


advertisement
More news
Image: Rajon Rondo
Getty Images
Not in his house

Rajon Rondo had 18 points, 10 assists and 10 rebounds and the Boston Celtics beat the Philadelphia 76ers 85-75 in Game 7 on Saturday night to advance to the Eastern Conference finals.

CSN: Rondo's big-game DNA shines  |  Highlights

CSN: You may not see it from start to finish, but when the game — or in this case, postseason life — is on the line, you see just how good Rajon Rondo can be.

Slideshow
Cleveland Cavaliers v Boston Celtics, Game Four
  NBA free agent signings
Check out where the top NBA free agents of 2010 have signed.

more photos

  ProBasketballTalk tweets

  1. Loading the latest posts…

Source: Twitter. For more, follow @basketballtalk.

Video: NBA from NBC Sports
PBT Extra: Can Thunder stun Spurs?
PBT Extra: Kurt Helin and Tiffany Simons discuss the matchup of the West's top two seeds in the conference finals, which begins Sunday.

  Ask the NBA expert: Ira Winderman

Do you have a burning NBA question? Submit it now, and then check back for our reader mailbag.

Slideshow
Philadelphia 76ers v Boston Celtics - Game Five
  Celebs shine at NBA playoffs
A look at the many celebrities who made appearances during this year's NBA playoffs.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Kevin Garnett
  Pictures of the postseason
Check out some of the best images from the 2012 NBA playoffs.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Minnesota Timberwolves v Detroit Pistons
  Get your cheer on
Check out some of the dancers from the NBA.

more photos

Slideshow
Image:
  The Week in Sports Pictures
A kayaker flips out, a racehorse eyes the Triple Crown and more.

more photos