Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Singing superstar Whitney Houston dies at 48

Offensive questions are not new to NFL draft

Teams usually ask blunt, sometimes uncomfortable queries to vet prospects

image: Bryant AP
The Cowboys drafted Dez Bryant 24th overall in the 2010 NFL draft.

Dan Pompei
If Dez Bryant had been interviewing with a Fortune 500 company, he never would have been subject to such humiliating questions, right?

Well, maybe not. But the NFL interview process is unlike any other. Part of what makes the NFL interviews different are the interviewees. “A lot of kids are from bad backgrounds — really bad backgrounds,” said one AFC college scouting director. “Most people listening to talk sports radio can’t even fathom it.”

And NFL teams have a lot more at stake in their player interviews than most businesses do in their employee interviews. Overlooking a significant aspect of a player’s past can cost people jobs and it can cost a team millions and millions of dollars.

Hearing that Dolphins general manager Jeff Ireland asked Bryant if his mother was a prostitute really isn’t surprising to anyone who has been a part of the process. And that is not meant to be a reflection of Ireland — a well respected and well liked member of the NFL community.

I have been fortunate enough to have sat in on about 20 team interviews of draft prospects. And the line of questioning always is blunt, sometimes uncomfortable and occasionally feels like a cross examination from a prosecuting attorney.

And players, at least those with decent agents, know exactly what is coming. Some will even start addressing touchy subjects before the questions come up.

At least two NFL teams indicated their reports on Bryant said they had been told Bryant’s father was a pimp and his mother was a prostitute. It may have been bad information. What we know for certain is Bryant’s mother has been arrested twice for selling crack cocaine. But whether she broke the law in other ways needed to be investigated, given the rumors.

Video
Oklahoma State v Texas
  PFTV: Did Ireland cross the line?
April 29, 2010: Mike Florio talks about Dez Bryant being asked inappropriate questions by Dolphins GM Jeff Ireland.
Why would a team have to know if Bryant’s mother were a prostitute? Well, think of it this way. Michael Vick grew up in a dog fighting culture. He remained in that culture after he made it in the NFL. What if Bryant grew up around prostitution and he remained associated with that culture?

Usually, NFL front office men already know the answers to their questions when they sit down with potential draftees. They just want to see how the athlete answers — or reacts.

Of course, there are ways to approach such subjects gently if all that is being sought is an honest answer. “You can ask them in a way that isn’t overtly offensive,” the AFC college scouting director said. “You can say, ‘There are rumors out there, and we want to clear them up if they are not true.’”

If a team executive is asking loaded questions that are potentially insulting merely to get a rise out of a player, he is crossing a line that probably should not be crossed.

At some point, if an interviewer does go too far, it could become a legal issue. According to Janis Whitaker, author of "Interviewing by Example," there are some questions you aren't allowed to ask. These include inquiries about race, weight, religion, citizen status, marital status, children, gender and disabilities.

"If you don't ask all candidates, it's probably some sort of discrimination," Whitaker told Inc.com.  "And if it's not specific to the job, [in employment law what is known as] a bona fide occupational qualification or BFOQ, in other words if it's a question that has nothing to do with job requirements, most likely it's discriminatory."

Up to this point, however, there have been no legal challenges to interviews, according to an NFL spokesman. Interestingly, some interviews are videotaped. Some are not.

Bryant wasn’t the only draft prospect who was asked touchy questions in interviews this year. One scout said he had to ask Abilene Christian offensive tackle Tony Washington, who went undrafted despite considerable ability, about being convicted for having sex with his 15 year old sister.

I was in a room with a top prospect in the 2007 draft when a team asked him if he ever smoked marijuana. He had, and he admitted it even though he had never been caught. That earned him points in the evaluation process.

Slideshow
California v Washington
  Top prospects for 2011 NFL draft
Evan Silva breaks down the 20 best players to keep an eye on for next year’s draft, including Washington QB Jake Locker.

NBCSports.com

Drug questions are commonplace in the NFL interview.

But really, the most valuable answers from NFL prospects are usually about their family.

“First, we want to know about his family background, how stable he is, his support structure,” Chiefs college scouting director Phil Emery said in an interview a few years ago. “Who is involved with him financially? Are there people depending on him? Does he come from a one-parent home? If he has a problem, who does he go to? We might need to put our player programs director on him, or we might need to pair him with a veteran who can be a good influence.”

Teams considering drafting players like Bryant need to know everything they can about them — and their families. But they also need to be sensitive and dignified in the process.


advertisement
More news
Image: Gerald Sensabaugh, Terence Newman, Mike Jenkins, DeSean Jackson
AP
Offseason needs for NFC teams

Silva: Each NFL team enters the offseason with a series of pressing needs. Sometimes a team can address them all, sometimes they ignore them all. But if a team's smart, they'll listen to us. These are the most crucial aspects for NFC teams.

Image: Wild Card Playoffs - Pittsburgh Steelers v Denver Broncos
Getty Images
Wesseling: Offseason priorities for AFC teams

Wesseling: Each NFL team enters the offseason with a series of pressing needs. Sometimes a team can address them all, sometimes they ignore them all. But if a team's smart, they'll listen to us. These are the most crucial aspects for AFC teams.