Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Mystery disease claims thousands in Central America

On-track retaliation may draw criminal charges

Legal ramifications could await drivers if they intentionally wreck others

Image: Brad Keselowski (left) and Carl EdwardsAP
Intentional on-track crashes could be subject to criminal penalties like aggravated assault if a driver or fan were injured.

If NASCAR drivers are going to retaliate against their fellow competitors, they might get more than three weeks probation because of it.

They could find themselves in trouble with the law.

Drivers should be aware that if they intentionally wreck another driver and someone is injured, they could face criminal penalties, according to Winston-Salem, N.C., attorney John Morrow, whose firm has represented Richard Childress Racing.

Whether the charges would stick and whether those injured could successfully bring civil claims against the driver is a matter of debate, according to lawyers and educators who follow sports law.

In Georgia for example, the definition of aggravated assault is "with a deadly weapon or with any object, device, or instrument which, when used offensively against a person, is likely to or actually does result in serious bodily injury."

If Brad Keselowski or a fan had been injured when Keselowski's car got airborne after intentional contact by Carl Edwards in the March 7 race at Atlanta Motor Speedway, would Edwards' action fit that assault definition?

"There certainly is a danger out there," Morrow said. "They're flirting with lawsuits. They race in about 20 states and every state has different laws. ... You can be convicted of assault with a deadly weapon in North Carolina if you intentionally run over somebody.

"And if you kill them, that can get up there in the murder class [of crimes]."

NASCAR requires race tracks to have $50 million in insurance for spectator injury, property damage, participant liability and product liability. Morrow, who successfully represented RCR in getting the life insurance paid on Dale Earnhardt after his death, said drivers should carry insurance to cover civil and criminal claims as well.

While race fans and fellow drivers might be hesitant to file lawsuits against a driver, a local prosecutor in the spotlight would face outside pressures and influences on whether to charge a race-car driver.

"District attorneys are elected officials," Morrow said. "Politics are part of the game. Let's say you did something like what happened at Atlanta and even admitted, 'Hell yeah I did it' and it was Dale Earnhardt [injured]. Do you think a district attorney might indict you to get votes and publicity?"

It certainly wouldn't be a cut-and-dried case. Most sports law dealing with intentional contact comes from hockey, where in 2000 Marty McSorley was convicted of assault for striking Donald Brashear in the head with his stick with three seconds left in a game.

Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

But other cases have indicated that even a hard check after the game has ended can be considered part of the sport. In 1998, an International Hockey League goalie tried to sue another player for a check that occurred several seconds after the final whistle. The case was dismissed because the Missouri state court of appeals ruled that "this body check, even several seconds after the whistle and in violation of several rules of the game, was not outside the realm of reasonable anticipation."

William Bray, a Charlotte attorney who has taught sports law classes at the University of North Carolina-Charlotte, said if Keselowski had been injured and tried to sue Edwards, the Roush Fenway Racing driver would need to be found to be reckless and not just simply negligent.

By competing in NASCAR, a driver consents to a level of contact, much like a boxer in the ring, Bray said.

"Keselowski would have an uphill battle," Bray said. "Edwards' attorney would point to 40 or 50 years of NASCAR and say there has been a lot worse that's happened out there.

"The first thing they would probably do would be to put a big PowerPoint in front of the jury that showed all these statements by the sanctioning body prior to the season about 'boys will be boys' and 'we will let them police themselves.'"

Bray said a driver would be more susceptible to a lawsuit for intentional contact if the driver was coming out of the pits and directly T-boned another driver rather than a push or nudge on the track that leads to injury or death.

"The analysis of this whole case would start with the level and nature of contact with Keselowski," Bray said. "I don't think there's anything exceptional about one driver in racing bumping or nudging another driver. Any resulting damages – from a civil standpoint or a criminal standpoint – the analysis is going to start there.

"Because that contact was relatively unexceptional in the sport, it's going to be an uphill battle for any claims for anybody."


advertisement
Slideshow
Kobalt Tools 500
  Earning a trip to victory lane
Take a look at every NASCAR driver who has claimed a checkered flag this racing season.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
SUBWAY Fresh Fit 600
  Revved up for racing
Take a look at how some NASCAR fans express their dedication to the drivers and to the sport.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Danica Patrick,  Helio Castroneves
  Danica Daze
Danica Patrick is expanding her repertoire from the IRL to NASCAR.

more photos

Slideshow
Coca-Cola 600
  Celebs at the track
Take a look at the stars who have attended NASCAR races.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Jeff Gordon, Jimmie Johnson, Mark Martin, Brian Vickers
  NASCAR crashes
Sparks fly and cars spin out wildly when NASCAR drivers get into accidents.

NBCSports.com

INTERACTIVE
"Taxi" Film Premiere
NASCAR wives and girlfriends
They're fixtures in pit row, but they don't drive on the track or work on the cars. Take a look at some notable NASCAR wives and girlfriends.