Skip navigation

Johnson isn't the best driver of all time yet

No. 48 will be a first-ballot Hall of Famer, but other drivers are still better

Image: Jimmie Johnson
Geoff Burke / Getty Images for NASCAR
Jimmie Johnson's on-track dominance puts him in the company of some of racing's best drivers of all-time.
Slideshow
Mark MArtin
  NASCAR crashes
Sparks fly and cars spin out wildly when NASCAR drivers get into accidents.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Ford 400
NASCAR champions
Take a look at the drivers who have raced their ways to series titles since the circuit's inception.
Slideshow
Coca-Cola 600
  Celebs at the track
Take a look at the stars who have attended NASCAR races.

NBCSports.com

INTERACTIVE
"Taxi" Film Premiere
NASCAR wives and girlfriends
They're fixtures in pit row, but they don't drive on the track or work on the cars. Take a look at some notable NASCAR wives and girlfriends.
Slideshow
Ford 400
  2009 winners
Take a look at every NASCAR driver who has claimed a checkered flag this season.

NBCSports.com

OPINION
By Jim Pedley
updated 12:30 p.m. ET Nov. 23, 2009

And so the debate officially begins. Where do we insert Jimmie Johnson on the list of best-ever drivers -- and won't this be fun?

Keeping in mind that Johnson is far from retiring and that his numbers could alter all of this: The curtain is pulled, the ballot is issued and here is one person's vote.

As a NASCAR wheelman: Johnson ranks third. In front of him are Richard Petty and David Peason.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

What the 2009 season showed me about Johnson is that he is not merely a product of the Hendrick system. Nor is he Chad Knaus' marionette. The guy can drive a stock car, you know? Perhaps he does not get the credit he deserves because he makes it look so dang easy. The great ones can do that.

Like on Sunday at Homestead. A bad decision to pit put him back with the squirrels. Just as you started thinking that that is what the Chase needed, he had worked his way clear of trouble and was setting sail for the top five.

The gap between first and third in this category is closer than you might think. Johnson may not have the numbers of Petty and Pearson, but those guys ran in different times. Times, some would argue, that were not as competitive as Johnson's.

As an American wheelman: Johnson slides down the list here. I rank him seventh. Not that that is bad when you consider that two of the guys in front of him -- Mario Andretti and A.J. Foyt -- are quite simply two of the absolute best of all time and not just in America. Only the great Ayrton Senna -- and perhaps Michael Schumacher -- ranks up there with those two on my ballot.

But I also put Al Unser Jr. ahead of Johnson. Little Al was incredible and does not get the credit he should have. He had the talent to win the world championship.

And I put Mark Donohue ahead of Johnson as well -- with an admission of personal bias.

Then, previously mentioned Petty and Pearson.

Johnson heads the group that includes John Force, Steve Kinser and now Tony Schumacher, Dale Earnhardt, Darrell Waltrip, Jeff Gordon and Hurley Haywood.

As a NASCAR Hall of Fame candidate: First ballot.

Slideshow
Image: Budweiser Shootout
  Week in Sports Pictures
The Saints triumph in the Super Bowl, Olympians work on final preparations for Vancouver, and more.

more photos

I figure Johnson will race another five years minimum. He has at least one more championship in him and at least 25 more race victories. All these are conservative estimates.

By the time he is eligible, Johnson will have shoo-in numbers and will still be young enough to look good at the induction ceremony.

(Note: In recent voting for the new NASCAR Hall of Fame, I did not vote for Pearson. Why do I rank him second as a wheelman and not vote him into the first class? Different deal. The HOF is not just about driving ability. It is about impact on the sport).

Jim Pedley is managing editor of Racin' Today. Read more NASCAR news at racintoday.com.

© 2009 Sporting News

Sponsored links