Skip navigation

Phillies find intimidating A-Rod not so easy

Maybe Philly should try hitting the baseball, not Yankees slugger

Slideshow
Image: New York Yankees player Jeter celebrates as he holds the World Series trophy with teammates in New YorK
  Yankees win their 27th World Series
Check out all the best action from the World Series.

more photos

Video: Baseball from NBC Sports
A speechless MVP
Joe Mauer thanks his teammates and talks about what it feels like to be the AL MVP.

Slide show
Image: Ding Jianjun
  Week in Sports Pictures
Pain on the skating rink, flying high on the hardwood, upsets on the football field, and more.

more photos

OPINION
By Mike Celizic
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 1:07 a.m. ET Nov. 2, 2009

Mike Celizic
Maybe it wasn’t such a good idea for the Phillies to keep plunking Alex Rodriguez.

It was a simple thought in the first inning when Phillies starter Joe Blanton drilled Alex Rodriquez, the third time in two nights the Yankees' clean-up hitter collected a contusion. And Blanton didn’t just hit A-Rod. He plunked him square in the back. It wasn’t a pitch meant to back A-Rod off the plate. It was meant to back him into the parking lot and out of the series.

For the rest of the game, it looked as if the strategy worked. A-Rod, who had slugged a two-run homer in Game 3 — his only hit of the Series — failed to deliver another hit.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Then the ninth arrived and brought A-Rod to the plate with Johnny Damon on third, Mark Teixeira on first, two outs on the scoreboard, a tie score, and Brad Lidge on the mound. On the second pitch, A-Rod ripped a double into left, the tie was broken, Mariano Rivera was warming up, and the Yankees had nabbed a 3-1 Series lead.

It’s impossible to tell whether the Phillies strategy of pelting him with baseballs contributed to the biggest hit A-Rod has ever had — so far. But if the idea was to intimidate him, it didn’t work. And if the idea was to wake him up, it did work.

Once or twice a generation, a pitcher admits to intentionally trying to implant a baseball between a hitter’s ribs. Every other hit batsman is always the result of “a pitch that got away from me.” So there will be no admission of intent from Blanton or the Phillies. There doesn’t have to be. We all know what they’ve been up to.

A-Rod took his two Game 3 plunkings without visible reaction. But when he got hit again in Game 4, he turned and looked long and inquiringly into the Yankee dugout, as if silently asking his teammates whether it would be all right to dash out to the mound to take a few swings at Blanton.

It might be in the regular season, which would provide great amusement to fans and fodder for commentators. In the World Series, when fights mean expulsions and maybe suspensions, it’s not a good idea. The Yankees are going to need A-Rod, and he knows it.

Slideshow
  Celebs in the stands
A look at some of the celebrities attending the 2009 MLB playoffs.

more photos

As it was, the Philadelphia crowd thought it was a great idea, despite the fact the Yankees were in the process of taking an early 2-0 lead. Seeing an opposing player — especially one from New York — get drilled is a source of delight to Philly fans, who couldn’t have been happier if Blanton had beaten up Santa Claus at second base with an arm ripped off a New York Ranger.

After putting the points of their heads together, the umpires decided that enough was enough and warned both teams that the next pitcher to intentionally throw at an opponent would be excused from further participation in the night’s entertainment.

But the deed was done, and whether it would blow up in the Phillies’ faces or spur them to victory over the hated New Yorkers (Yes, I know. In Philadelphia, that’s redundant.) remains to be seen.

On the face of it, it’s a dangerous idea. A-Rod’s bat was absent from the first two game of this Series. In Game 3, he started to wake up. And that's not something Philly should want.

“That one time I got hit in (Saturday's) game — my first at-bat — that kind of woke me up a little bit and just reminded me, hey, this is the World Series, let's get it going a little bit. So it worked out,” Rodriguez told reporters after Game 4.

A-Rod's the most dangerous, the most controversial, the most loathed and one of the most popular players on the Yankees, which is saying a lot. The point is, he’s not the player any team wants to wake up. If he gets himself worked up into a hot streak, that’s the end of the series.

Philadelphia seems to be willing to take that uncertain chance. Maybe the Phillies have bought the perceived wisdom that A-Rod is a bit of a wuss, and that he can be intimidated. Or maybe they feel that a good way to fire up their own team is to draw a bulls-eye on the back of the other team’s most potent player.


Sponsored links