Skip navigation

Is Yanks’ mix of money, ‘Moneyball’ dynastic?

N.Y. built $210 million team smartly, with an eye toward several titles

Image: Angels vs Yankees
Mike Segar / Reuters
The Yankees spent a bundle on CC Sabathia this offseason, but it was actually a smart buy, writes Johnette Howard.
Slideshow
Image: New York Yankees player Jeter celebrates as he holds the World Series trophy with teammates in New YorK
  Yankees win their 27th World Series
Check out all the best action from the World Series.

more photos

Video: Baseball from NBC Sports
Nats name Riggleman
Jim Riggleman was officially introduced as the manager of the Washington Nationals.

OPINION
By Johnette Howard
NBCSports.com
updated 9:24 p.m. ET Oct. 28, 2009

Johnette Howard

If you’re wondering how the Yankees got back to being World Series favorites again this year — or, more correctly, what took them so freaking long, given the obscene stacks of cash they’ve been spending? — Billy Beane, the Oakland A’s coupon-clipping general manager, would seem like the last guy to be conflicted about the answer.

It’s the money, stupid. Right? How hard is it to build a $210-million contender like the Yankees have done?

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Yet there is Beane on page 275 of “Moneyball,” the seminal 2004 book that laid out his number-crunching way of assembling a team, almost absolving the Yankees’ recent playoff flops by allowing that once any team gets to the playoffs, “My s--- doesn’t work … What happens after that is f------ luck.”

Then, wait — now here’s Beane on page 141 of this year’s best-seller, “The Yankee Years,” seemingly contradicting his crapshoot theory by telling Joe Torre’s co-author, Tom Verducci, that maybe you really can hoard so much talent that, “At some point, a team becomes so good that they overcome the randomness.”

“The ’98 Yankees were one of the greatest teams I ever saw,” Beane continued. “They had everything you’d want a baseball team to have.”

The 2009 Yankees could be a juggernaut in ascent. Yankees general manager Brian Cashman, knowing the club was moving into a $1.5 billion stadium and coming off a year in which they missed the postseason for the first time in 13 years, threw $423.5 million at just three players this offseason: CC Sabathia, A.J. Burnett, and Mark Teixeira. He traded for free-spirited Nick Swisher, coaxed Andy Pettitte into sticking around, and gave some young homegrown guys a chance.

Slideshow
Image: Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim v New York Yankees, Game 6
  Baseball playoffs: Day 15
Check out all the best action from the MLB playoffs.

more photos

Now look: The 2009 Yankees are a team that hits for average, hits for power, boasts a forbidding starting rotation, a resourceful bench and their deepest bullpen in years. The Yankees won their first AL East title since 2006. They broke their galling string of three consecutive first-round playoff losses by pulling the feisty little Minnesota Twins apart limb by limb like some overcooked little rotisserie chickens in a 3-0 sweep. Then they leaped to a fast start in this week’s AL Championship Series against the Los Angeles Angels, their nemesis most of this decade. Even Alex Rodriguez has looked clutch.

This is all a lousy development if you’re cheering against a Yankees’ renaissance. But that is not the worst news a Yankee hater could hear.

That would be this:

This powerhouse Yankees team we’re seeing now is what can happen when the Yankees combine their bottomless checking account with some of the Moneyball–style statistical modeling that Beane and Red Sox stats guru Bill James popularized.

The Yankees this season spent nearly $70 million more than the next closest big-payroll team, the Mets. They also spent smarter.

After signing far too many bust pitchers, Cashman admitted he more actively investigated the character of each new player this time around. Since taking sole control of the everyday baseball operations in 2006, Cashman has relied more on statistical analysis than he ever did, to the point it caused some friction with Torre before Torre walked away after the 2007 season from a one-year contract offer that seemed designed for Torre to refuse.


Sponsored links