Skip navigation

Greinke deserves AL Cy Young Award

Youngster's 2.16 ERA on lousy Royals team should give him nod

Image: Greinke
G. Newman Lowrance / Getty Images
What Zack Greinke did on a very bad Royals team truly was special. A 2.16 ERA in the American League?
Video: Baseball from NBC Sports
A speechless MVP
Joe Mauer thanks his teammates and talks about what it feels like to be the AL MVP.

Slide show
Image: Ding Jianjun
  Week in Sports Pictures
Pain on the skating rink, flying high on the hardwood, upsets on the football field, and more.

more photos

ASK THE MLB EXPERT
By Tony DeMarco
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 8:56 p.m. ET Nov. 16, 2009

Tony DeMarco
The Yankees have put the wraps on a 27th championship and the hot stove is getting into full swing, so the big thing to do now is to count ballots and pick some award winners. Here are one voter's winning picks:

AL MVP: 1) Joe Mauer, Minnesota; 2) Derek Jeter, New York; 3) Mark Teixeira, New York; 4) Miguel Cabrera, Detroit; 5) Kevin Youkilis, Boston; 6) Kendry Morales, Los Angeles; 7) Michael Young, Texas; 8) Adam Lind, Toronto; 9) Ichiro Suzuki, Seattle; 10) Chone Figgins, Los Angeles.

The Twins getting to the postseason only helped Mauer — not that he needs it. The dramatic boost in power to go with a third batting title in four years and the Gold Glove defense should be more than enough.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

When you're clearly the best team in the regular season, there is room for two — Jeter and Teixeira — near the top. Especially with Cabrera deserving to drop a few spots for his drunken issues with the division title on the line during the final weekend.

NL MVP: 1) Albert Pujols, St. Louis; 2. Hanley Ramirez, Florida; 3. Prince Fielder, Milwaukee; 4) Troy Tulowitzki, Colorado; 5) Ryan Howard, Philadelphia; 6) Pablo Sandoval, San Francisco; 7) Matt Kemp, Los Angeles; 8) Ryan Braun, Milwaukee; 9) Chase Utley, Philadelphia; 10) Adrian Gonzalez, San Diego.

The only question is if Pujols will be a unanimous winner. Ramirez and Fielder — the two who kept Pujols from a Triple Crown — come next in the absence of standout candidates on the other playoff qualifiers.

Tulowitzki's season mirrored the Rockies' climb under Jim Tracy, and imagine what Panda Sandoval could do with better hitters around him.

AL Cy Young Award: 1) Zack Greinke, Kansas City; 2. Felix Hernandez, Seattle; 3. Roy Halladay, Toronto.

What Greinke did on a very bad Royals team truly was special. A 2.16 ERA in the American League? Did they raise the mounds, and we didn't find out? Six complete games and three shutouts speak to his dominance — and he received only 4.83 runs per game of support, or he could have won 20.

That said, Hernandez won three more games than Greinke, and had very slight edges in innings, percentage of quality starts, opponents' batting average, on-base percentage and slugging percentage.

Halladay threw nine complete games and four shutouts.

NL Cy Young Award: 1) Tim Lincecum, San Francisco; 2) Adam Wainwright, St. Louis; 3) Chris Carpenter, St. Louis.

Slideshow
  Celebs in the stands
A look at some of the celebrities attending the 2009 MLB playoffs.

more photos

Tough call here, as Wainwright won four more games than Lincecum, his ERA was only 0.15 higher, and he racked up a league-leading 233 innings.

But Lincecum got 1.24 fewer runs per game of support, threw four complete games and two shutouts (as opposed to one complete game for Wainwright) and had a higher percentage of quality starts.

Lincecum also was far more dominant, striking out 49 more hitters, and posting significantly lower numbers in opponents' batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage and WHIP.

AL Manager of the Year: 1) Ron Gardenhire, Minnesota; 2) Don Wakamatsu, Seattle; 3) Mike Scioscia, Los Angeles.

Hopefully, the thrilling play-in game will ram home what already should be common knowledge: Gardenhire's teams play the game the way it's supposed to be played.

It really would be interesting to see what Gardenhire could do with a $100-million-plus payroll, considering how much he gets out of the Twins' small-to-mid-market rosters: Five division titles, a 2008 play-in game loss, and two third-place division finishes in his eight seasons.

NL Manager of the Year: 1) Jim Tracy, Colorado; 2) Bruce Bochy, San Francisco; 3) Tony La Russa, St. Louis.

What Tracy did in turning around the Rockies in four-plus months is remarkable. From 18-28 and last place in late-May, all the way to the brink of erasing a 15 1/2-game division deficit before settling for the wild card and the league's third-best record.

Tracy is a players' manager and one of the nicest people in the game, but don't let the aw-shucks demeanor fool you. He's extremely tough-minded and has a knack for putting players into situations where they can succeed.

Tony DeMarco is a contributor to NBCSports.com and a freelance writer based in Denver.

Sponsored links