Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Mickelson a marvel at Pebble Beach, while Tiger tumbles

Should Canada turn to Brodeur or Luongo?

Goalie contenders prompt questions that could make it roster's weakest

LUONGOAP file
After his poor playoff performance for the Canucks, some are wondering if Roberto Luongo is only a contender to be Canada's No. 1 goalie in the Olympics because the Games will be in Vancouver.

Roberto Luongo was still at the airport after arriving in Calgary when the questions started. How was he going to beat out Martin Brodeur for Team Canada's starting goalie job?

"The only thing I can do is play, I don't make the decisions," Luongo answered. "Obviously, Marty is tremendous, not only for the NHL, but Team Canada. That's going to be up to the top management to decide."

But the management has to decide more than just who will start. The depth in goal for Team Canada is impressive, but each of the top contenders prompt questions that could make the position the weakest on the roster.

Let the debate begin.

The case for Brodeur:
He has the Olympic experience, having been the starter for Team Canada in the last two Olympics. He won the gold medal with Team Canada in 2002, and it's hard to find a more competitive person. Brodeur says he feels great physically and looks forward to the competition to start in goal for Canada.

"Brodeur's body of work internationally, in the NHL and at the most critical times, speaks for itself," said former NHL G.M. Craig Button.

"A guy like Martin Brodeur has always shown he's not going to let his team out of a game."

The case for Luongo: When he's on his game, there's not a better goalie in the NHL. "That's the one player I would have seriously moved Vincent Lecavalier to pick him up," said former Tampa Bay Lightning G.M. Jay Feaster. "He's such a difference-maker. By himself, he wins games for you."

Luongo had nine shutouts last season, despite playing only 54 games. He also finished in the top five in both save percentage and goals-against average.

Plus, he'd be playing in front of his home crowd in Vancouver.

"It would be a special feeling," Luongo said.

The case against Brodeur: There have been signs Brodeur's game is on the decline. The Devils have underachieved in the postseason the last two years and part of the reason is because of Brodeur's inability to make the big save at the most crucial of moments. But his teammates aren't blaming Brodeur.

"There are a lot of things that go into teams winning and losing. I'd never be the one to point the finger at Marty Brodeur," New Jersey forward Jamie Langenbrunner told Sporting News. "There's not a more competitive guy who has accomplished more in big games."

The case against Luongo: It's hard to forget his inability to hold Vancouver's lead against the Blackhawks in the Western Conference semifinals. While Brodeur has helped lead teams to Stanley Cups and gold medals, Luongo's postseason track record is spotty at best. For an elite goalie, his 11-11 career playoff record is anything but.

"What has he done? Last year in the playoffs, Chicago beat Vancouver because (Nikolai) Khabibulin was better than Luongo," said one NHL source. "For me, they might keep Luongo only because it's in Vancouver and who he is."

Our pick: Brodeur. His track record and experience will be too much for Team Canada coach Mike Babcock to pass up.

The fight for the final spot
If Brodeur represents Team Canada's goalie present, the three players fighting for the No. 3 spot on the roster could be the future. Carolina's Cam Ward, Columbus' Steve Mason and Pittsburgh's Marc-Andre Fleury are the contenders at Canada's orientation camp this week, and they're likely fighting for the same roster spot. The winner could also be an indication of who will carry the goalie torch in future Olympics.

"It was supposed to be handed over to Luongo, but all of a sudden there's a bunch of fresh faces that have shown up on the scene," said former NHL goalie Ron Tugnutt, a consultant for Canada's junior team. "Cam Ward, Fleury and of course, Mason — plus I don't even think Carey Price (Montreal) is that far off the picture, either."

Ranking the contenders:

© 2012 Sporting News

advertisement
More news
Washington Capitals v New York Rangers
NHLI via Getty Images
Rangers extend lead in East

Ryan Callahan scored for the fifth time in four days and defenseman Ryan McDonagh snapped a second-period tie to lift the New York Rangers to a 3-2 victory over the Washington Capitals on Sunday.

Washington Capitals v New York Rangers
NBC Sports
Highlights: Capitals - Rangers

  Check out highlights from the Rangers 3-2 win over the Capitals.

Slideshow
Chicago Blackhawks v New Jersey Devils
  Devil of a goalie
New Jersey's Martin Brodeur, the winningest netminder in NHL history.
Video: NHL from NBC Sports
Washington Capitals v New York Rangers
NHLI via Getty Images
Highlights: Capitals - Rangers
Check out highlights from the Rangers 3-2 win over the Capitals.

Slideshow
Image: Chicago Blackhawks Marian Hossa of Team Chara celebrates his goal with New York Rangers Marion Gaborik during the NHL All-Star hockey game in Ottawa
  NHL All-Stars
Take a look at the players who competed in Team Chara's 12-9 victory over Team Alfredsson.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Stanley Cup Finals - Pittsburgh Penguins v Detroit Red Wings - Game Seven
  Sid the Kid
Penguins captain Sidney Crosby has gone from phenom to Stanley Cup champion.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Washington Capitals Ovechkin celebrates his goal against the Montreal Canadiens during Game 5 in Washington
  Alexander the Great
Take a look at Capitals star and two-time MVP Alexander Ovechkin

more photos

Slideshow
Pamela Anderson
  Celebrity fans
Some of Hollywood's hottest celebrities take in NHL games.
Slideshow
Colorado Avalanche v Anaheim Ducks
  Icy Hot
Check out the ice girls from around the National Hockey League.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

  Special feature
Dallas Stars v Detroit Red Wings - Game Five
Getty Images

Turco, Nabokov among those
that need big 2009-10 season

  Special feature
Ryan Suter, David Backes, John Oshie, Jack Johnson, Kyle Okposo
AP

Forwards, defensemen and
goalies likely to suit up in ’10