Skip navigation

Tiger’s defeat at PGA is golf’s gain

Not only does defeat prove Woods is human, it shows he can be even better

Image: Tiger Woods
Streeter Lecka / Getty Images
Tiger Woods reacts to his missed birdie putt on the second hole during the final round of the 91st PGA Championship on Sunday.
Slideshow
PGA Championship - Final Round
  2009 PGA Championship
Take a look at fourth-round action from "Glory's last shot."

more photos

  Golf on NBC
Image: Johnny Miller (left) and Dan Hicks

Next up: The Honda Classic
March 6: 3 - 6 p.m.
March 7: 3 - 6 p.m.
Golf on NBC | 2010 schedule

Slideshow
Tiger Woods,  Elin Woods
  Tiger and family
Images of star golfer with wife Elin Nordegren and their kids.

more photos

Latest golf video
All about Steve
Dan Hicks and Johnny Miller talk about Steve Stricker's impressive performance in Los Angeles.

Slideshow
Image:
  Tiger Woods in cartoons
See some of the best commentaries on Tiger's scandal.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Houston Rockets v Los Angeles Lakers, Game 5
  Phil and family
Take a look at photos of Phil Mickelson, his wife Amy and children.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: PGA Championship - Final Round
  Wanamaker Trophy winners
Take a look at the golfers who have won the PGA Championship.

more photos

Slideshow
2006 PGA Championship - Round Two
  PGA Championship history
Take a look at the past records set in the final PGA Tour major of the year.

more photos

OPINION
By Dan O'Neill
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 6:51 p.m. ET Aug. 17, 2009

Dan O'Neill
CHASKA, Minn. - Perhaps there was a lesson to be learned in what took place at Hazeltine National Golf Club on Sunday, a lesson for Tiger Woods, a lesson for all of us.

Woods began the final round of the PGA Championship with a two-stroke lead. Woods with the lead on Sunday is like Kirstie Alley with cheesecake on her plate, you can bet it’s going to be put away. Woods, who had never been caught from behind during the final round of a major, started Sunday with a perfect 14-for-14 mark with the lead or a share of it after 54 holes.

With that in mind, how could you expect any different. When he gets the lead on Sunday, the world's No. 1 player has adapted a prevent defense. He puts away the driver, for the most part, sets the accelerator on cruise and starts humming a Dave Clark Five song: "Catch Us If You Can."

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Woods didn't believe anyone could, nor did anyone else. And time, after time, after time, no one does. Like clockwork, when Woods assumes a threatening position, the competition cowers and cries "Uncle." Sometimes just one player turtles, sometimes a bunch of them do. It has become so inevitable that a betting house in England began paying off those who bet on Tiger to win this PGA Championship a day early.

The 33-year-old Woods, winner of 70 PGA Tour events, attended Stanford and picks out his own outfits a year ahead of time — i.e. he’s no dummy. He has employed a finishing method that presents the least amount of risk in order to achieve the maximum result. Actually, giving Woods' ownership of the blueprint is a little off base. Many major champions have walked the same walk over the years, including one named Nicklaus.

The bottom line is Woods knows he need not go out and win a tournament he leads, he need only be careful not to lose it. For the better part of his final round on Sunday, the better-safe-than-sorry system was in play and working beautifully. Woods kept the training wheels on, hit the middle of the greens, lagged his puts effectively and made pars. Nothing ventured, everything gained.

When Padraig Harrington — perceived to be the most serious threat — self-destructed for a second week in succession, the auto-pilot was humming. Harrington went from one stroke back and a tie for second to six back and tied for 11th in one horrific hole. A snowman in Minnesota is certainly appropriate, but there is a time and place for everything. The eighth hole at Hazeltine on Sunday was no time to pack snow.

Harrington won two majors while Woods was out of action last year. But he has now collapsed during head-to-head showdowns on consecutive weeks. As Harrington walked off with his quintuple-bogey, somewhere Casey Stengel had to be muttering, "Can’t anybody here play this game?"

The runway appeared to be clear once more; a 15th major championship seemed to be a formality for Woods. Who could blame Woods for being lulled into sleep.

“I was in control of the tournament most of the day,” said Woods, who finished with a final-round 3-over 75. “I was playing well, hitting the ball well. I was making nothing, but still either tied for the lead or ahead.”

But golf is not supposed to be like that. It should not be so predictable, so monotonous, so irrefutable. Finally, someone reminded us of that. Finally, someone did not go quietly.

While no one was taking Y.E. Yang seriously, he was taking his time, playing alongside Woods in the final pairing, sticking like a rash. Still in position to strike, Yang got the break he needed, a miraculous chip-in from the rough on No. 14 that rolled across the green and into the cup for an eagle. The shot seemed to awaken Woods, who responded with an 8-foot putt for birdie.

But the exchange gave Yang a one-stroke lead with four holes to play. Repeat, this is not Harrington, Lucas Glover, Vijay Singh, Ernie Els, Sergio Garcia, Phil Mickelson, Anthony Kim or any number of "name" players who have failed to collar Woods over the years. Someone named Yang had restored the concept that nothing is pre-ordained and no one is invulnerable, not even ... (pause to clear your throat) ... Tiger Woods.

“I don’t think anyone has ever gone 14-for-14 or 15-for-15,” Woods said afterward. “So I certainly ... like today, I played well enough to win the championship. I did not putt well enough to win the championship. I didn’t get it done on the greens and consequently, I didn’t win the tournament.”


Sponsored links