Skip navigation
Listen now:
NBC Sports: The Dan Schwartzman Show

At some colleges, cheerleading counts as a sport

But move controversial as some see it as cheap way to comply with Title IX

Special feature
Miami of Ohio v Michigan
College cheer
Check out some of the college football cheerleaders from across the country.

NBCSports.com

HAMDEN, Conn. - They jump, tumble and work the crowd. They also bristle at being called cheerleaders.

“We don’t even use that word anymore,” said Tori Maynard, a senior on the University of Oregon’s competitive cheer team. “It’s a stereotype. People don’t understand what competitive cheerleading is.”

Maynard and others involved in competitive cheer say it is a sport, similar to gymnastics. A smattering of colleges agree, some seeing it as a cheaper way to help comply with Title IX, the federal law that requires schools to offer equal athletic opportunities to men and women.

“You don’t chant, you don’t yell for any other teams,” said Maynard, who hails from Lake Charles, La. “You compete. You do a gymnastics portion, you do a jump portion, you do a team portion. You don’t cheer. Other people cheer for you.”

Not everyone is cheering the rise of competitive cheer — especially those in the fight to expand women’s collegiate sports. They say cheerleading is a support activity, like a marching band, and claim calling it a sport just gives universities an excuse to eliminate more recognized women’s teams.

“Right now girls are vastly underrepresented on college rosters,” said Nancy Hogshead-Makar, an attorney for the Women’s Sports Foundation. “I would hate to see viable sports that lead to Olympic possibilities, international opportunities, thwarted in favor of a sport that doesn’t lead to any of those.”

Quinnipiac University in Connecticut pointed to the recession when it announced a plan this spring to cut three sports, including women’s volleyball, an established collegiate and Olympic sport.

But it was volleyball’s proposed replacement — elevating the school’s cheerleading team to sports status — that launched a campus controversy.

In a federal lawsuit, Quinnipiac volleyball coach Robin Sparks argued that replacing her team with cheer violated the spirit of Title IX and would be a step backward for women in sports. After all, she testified, her grandmother was able to be a cheerleader.

“To me, Title IX is about giving women opportunities beyond that,” she said.

Schools have three ways to comply with Title IX: Match the proportionality of female athletes to female students on campus, show a history of increasing sports for women, or prove the school has met the interest and ability of the underrepresented group.

To the schools, the benefit of a competitive cheer team is more athletic opportunities for women at lower cost. Quinnipiac’s cheer team includes 40 roster spots and a budget of about $50,000, or $1,250 per roster spot. The volleyball team had a budget of more than $70,000 for 11 players last season, costing the school more than $6,300 for each team member.

During a hearing in the Quinnipiac case, school cheer coach Mary Ann Powers defended her athletes and said most are elite gymnasts.

She also lamented how the issue has turned supporters of women’s athletics into adversaries. “I think what offends (cheerleaders) more than anything is other women degrading them and knocking what they do,” she testified.

But is cheerleading a sport? Judge Stefan Underhill, who is presiding over the Quinnipiac lawsuit, didn’t rule it out. Underhill granted an injunction to keep the school’s volleyball team in place and said the team is likely to win its Title IX claim. The lawsuit is in settlement talks.

Slideshow
Notre Dame v UCLA
  Three cheers for Madness
Take a look at cheerleaders in action during the NCAA tournament and more.

more photos

But his ruling focused more on evidence that Quinnipiac falsely inflated the rosters of other women’s teams — and undercounted members of men’s teams — to create an illusion of gender equity. Underhill determined that competitive cheer “although not presently an NCAA recognized sport or emerging sport, has all the necessary characteristics of a potentially valid competitive sport.”

An activity can be considered a sport under Title IX if it meets specific criteria. It must have coaches, practices, competitions during a defined season, and a governing organization. The activity also must have competition as its primary goal — not merely the support of other athletic teams.

Because the Quinnipiac competitive cheer team would only compete against other teams, it meets that standard. So do the cheer teams at a handful of other schools such as Oregon and Maryland, which in 2003 became the first school to create a separate cheer team for competitions. Maryland officials declined to comment for this story because of the Quinnipiac litigation.

No cheer team can win a NCAA national championship, only one awarded by a group affiliated with a for-profit corporation. The national cheer title is bestowed by the National Cheerleaders Association, which hosts competitions, as does the Universal Cheerleading Association. Both are tied to Varsity Brands Inc., which makes cheerleading apparel and runs camps.

Routines are scored like gymnastics. Teams are judged on tumbling, acrobatic throws and dance.


advertisement
More news
NBC Sports
Previewing France’s great cycling spectacle

  In the near 100 years of the Tour de France, almost nothing has changed. A victor is crowned and their lives forever changed with the distinction of being a Tour de France champion.  Join us as we preview France’s great cycling spectacle.

CYCLING-FRA-TDF2012-CRASH
NBC Sports
Grim crashes of the Tour de France

  While riders may not agree, cycling crashes are the most fascinating of any sport. With little to no protection, a rider coming up bloodied is a common sight. Join as we take a look at some of the most gruesome crashes from Tour de France history.

Tour de France Stage 17
NBC Sports
Rewriting Armstrong's legacy

  Lance Armstrong was the poster child for cycling and the Tour de France, but because of USADA's ruling, Armstrong's legacy is in ruins.

Slide show

more photos

Special feature
"American Woman: Fashioning A National Identity" Met Gala - Arrivals
When athletes and celebs get together
A look at the many links between sports and Hollywood stars.

NBCSports.com

Detroit Tigers v Minnesota Twins
Getty Images
Slideshow
Denver Nuggets v Golden State Warriors - Game Three
  Get your NBA cheer on
Check out some of the dancers from the NBA.

more photos

Slideshow
Image:
  Sideline support
Check out some of the NFL cheerleaders from across the league.

NBCSports.com