Skip navigation

Is a human life worth only a judge's love tap?

Compared to Vick's sentence, Stallworth ruling doesn't make any sense

Slideshow
Popeye Jones
  BUSTED!
Popeye Jones is just one athlete with an unflattering booking photo. NBCSports.com looks at mugshots through the years.

more photos

Video
  Cowboys-Eagles highlights
Nov. 8: Miles Austin's 49-yard touchdown catch in the fourth quarter lifted the Cowboys over the Eagles in Week 9.

NBC Sports

Video: Football from NBC Sports
Elite QB battle
Nov. 8: With Week 10's SNF game pitting the two QBs of the decade, Al Michaels and Cris Collinsworth wonder what kind of accolades Peyton Manning might have earned if he didn't have to face the Patriots so many times.

Video
Arizona Cardinals v Chicago Bears
  Is Kurt Warner like Johnny U?
Peter King's notebook: A report on the future of the Cardinals quarterback, the Browns' general manager search and Cedric Benson's performance.

NBC Sports

Special feature
Green Bay Packers v Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Vote for supremacy
Who gets your vote: Will the pom-poms win another one or get crushed by the coozy?
Slideshow
Atlanta Falcons v New Orleans Saints
  Sideline support
Check out some of the NFL cheerleaders from across the league.

more photos

Slide show
Image:
  Week in Sports Pictures
A Duck goes for a ride, a NASCAR driver takes flight, some bankers take to boxing, and much more.

more photos

OPINION
By Shaun Powell
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 8:39 p.m. ET June 17, 2009

Image: Shaun Powell
Shaun Powell
The sad part is he will be released in time for training camp, free to enjoy the trivial pursuit of flying footballs, unless no-nonsense NFL commissioner Roger Goodell does what the legal system couldn’t: keep the handcuffs on Donte' Stallworth a while longer.

A 59-year old man will never again see his wife or hold his daughter because he was killed while crossing the street by Stallworth, who was legally tipsy and speeding in Miami Beach at the time. And after lawyering up and copping pleas and buying off the family of Mario Reyes, Stallworth got off with 30 wrist-slapping days, a hell of a lot lighter than Michael Vick did, even in dog years.

There’s something atrociously wrong with this, when a human life doesn’t weigh the same as an animal’s on the scales of justice, or in our society, for that matter. Notice there was no national outcry on behalf of Reyes, no special interest group picketing in his memory, not even a tear shed by Pekingese owners.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Just like Vick’s dogs, Reyes was innocent and defenseless when his fate was sealed by a reckless NFL player whose punishment for drinking and driving, handed down yesterday, seems a lot flimsier than a David Letterman apology.

Well, OK, let’s concede the apples-to-oranges details of the cases between Vick and Stallworth. Vick lied to the feds about running and bankrolling a dogfighting outfit that caused the brutal destruction of dogs, strictly for entertainment. Had he fessed and showed remorse from the get-go, Vick might have side-stepped significant jail time as easily as he would a clumsy linebacker. Instead, he refused to man up, and for that, he got 23 months. That’s about the right price to pay for being a chump.

Stallworth was a lot smarter in the immediate aftermath of taking someone’s life. He did not gun the gas pedal of his Bentley and flee after hitting Reyes. He quickly wrote a check to grieving family members and essentially bought their silence; there will be no further public outcry from them. Then he used another chunk of the millions he gets from the Cleveland Browns to hire a competent defense team. He didn’t murder anyone, and for pleading guilty to second-degree DUI manslaughter, he caught a sympathetic vote of confidence from the system.

Vick was a cold killer, Stallworth an unintentional one. True enough. Their motives were different. No doubt.

And so what?

Nothing changes the lopsided verdict.

Almost two years for Vick?

Not even two months for Stallworth?

For whatever reason, our justice system gets weak in the knees when it comes to certain manslaughter cases, especially those involving athletes with enough money to sway the circumstances in their favor. It’s downright criminal that Stallworth got 30 days while his victim got life, especially in light of the hammer laid on Vick.

But such is the lucky fate of too many athletes who indirectly cause someone’s death. Susan Gutweiler might agree if she could, except she was killed by a drunk St. Louis Rams defensive end, and the best that justice could whip up for Leonard Little was 90 days and four years probation. Hell, why didn’t the prosecutors just ask for his autograph? Just to show how “reformed” he was, Little was arrested for drunk driving six years later and escaped with a speeding ticket as punishment. Even worse, during all this, he continued to be hailed as a football hero and cheered by Rams fans who forgot about Susan Gutweiler for three hours on Sunday afternoons.

Gus Christofi, too, might wonder why Jayson Williams never served a day in jail for flipping a loaded shotgun in the direction of the limo driver, then frantically orchestrating a cover-up when the gun went off, killing Christofi. But we all know why this outcome was bound to happen. The family of Christofi snatched a $2.75 million settlement almost before the ink was dry on the check, and the best defense attorneys money could buy made sure Williams would suffer a lot less than Christofi.

If Jim Leyritz still had the millions he made in Major League Baseball, you think he’d still be in the mess he’s in now, after killing a mother while driving drunk?

When someone decides to drink and then take the wheel, they should not get a love tap by a judge’s gavel. Their time for showing remorse should’ve been when they turned the key in the ignition. Anything that happens next, particularly if it involves taking someone’s life, must be weighed at punishment time, and no amount of money or fame or athletic ability should minimize the sentence.

Or would you disagree, if that were your father or husband who crossed the road in Miami Beach that morning?

Donte' Stallworth might be a nice guy, upstanding citizen, decent football player and all that, but when he mixed the most toxic of all drinks — alcohol and car keys — he indirectly chose to pay a steep price for stupidity. Except the price wasn’t so steep after all.

Eventually, he’ll get back on the field, and catch passes, and score touchdowns, and a football nation will judge him on that. Meanwhile, the most famous dog killer in history will always be judged by his crime, instead of any footballs he throws from here.

The commissioner of the NFL, sensitive to law-breaking football players who take their God-given talent and good fortune for granted, will surely put Stallworth on the bench to start the season. Too bad Goodell can’t put him where he truly belongs.

Shaun Powell writes regularly for NBCSports.com and is a freelance writer based in New York.

Sponsored links