Skip navigation
Listen now:
NBC Sports: The Jason Page Show

Time for the death of bracketology

College basketball is not a science, so stop trying to make it one

Mike Celizic
Bracketology.

It’s an ugly, loathsome word, invented by people eager to elevate something of little relevance to the level of a science.

You turn on the television to watch a conference basketball tournament. All you want is to enjoy the game, get to know some of the teams and get in the mood for the glorious NCAA tournament to come. But the joy is sucked out of it by this awful word and the hyperbabble of the breathless analysts who can speak of little else.

I just want to see if Providence can hang in with Louisville. I care if the Friars make the NCAA tournament as much as I care how many angels can dance on the head of a metaphor. If they get in, good for them. They’re not going past the second round anyway, and it’s doubtful they’d get that far.

But all the analyst talks about is the bubble and quality wins and RPI and strength of schedule and what the Friars have to do to be one of the 50 or 55 teams who have as much chance of winning March Madness as Jim Cramer has of winning the Nobel Prize in Economics.

Can’t they just give it a rest? I mean, it’s not that important, folks. We’re not talking about the future of the Republic.

I understand that it’s important to be one of the top seeds in college basketball’s annual spring prom. And I know that fans of individual teams teetering on the dreaded bubble are consumed with a mixture of hope that their heroes will get in and dread that they won’t.

And I know that these things have meaning to schools and conferences. Getting a top seed is one of those bragging rights things, like being best-in-breed at a dog show. But it doesn’t mean you’re going to be the team cutting down the nets in Detroit the first week of April. And making the tournament — even for a one-and-done appearance — means money in the coffers of the universities and conferences involved. It also helps with recruiting and gives students in college towns everywhere an excuse to get in a road trip.

But, come on, folks. None of it is nearly as important as the breathless analysts make it out to be. There’s little actual difference between a one seed and a two seed. The proof of that is the fact that last year was the first time in the history of the tournament that all the No. 1 seeds made it to the Final Four. If it were that big a deal, you’d expect it to happen all the time.

NCAA tournament projections
Who’s dancing next year?
The 2010 men's NCAA tournament’s now complete, so let's turn to next season. We project the field of 64. Where is your team?

NBCSports.com

Then there are all those bubble teams. The analysts who are destroying my viewing pleasure talk as if it’s more important than Octomom and Britney’s comeback tour. But I can’t believe that many fans of the game really care who fills out the bottom of the tournament barrel. No matter which team it is, they’re still not getting very far in the bracket you fill out for the office pool.

The cool thing about conference tournament week is the sheer intensity of the games and the familiarity of the opponents. Everybody knows everybody else intimately and the games are played in front of fans who are rabid about what they’re watching.

Special feature
Big Dance hopefuls
Highlights which teams are in good shape for the NCAA tournament — and which are starting to sweat

NBCSports.com

The top teams use the week to hone their games to the fine edge they’re going to need starting next week, when the real fun begins. The bottom feeders are spilling their guts in the desperate hope of knocking off one of the giants and maybe forcing their way into the NCAA tournament.

Baylor knocked off Kansas, the top seed in the Big 12, Thursday. The win may or may not get Baylor into the NCAA tournament, and I got to be honest: I don’t care. It was a great game to watch and it showed that maybe the Jayhawks aren’t quite as strong as we all thought they were.

The bracketologists, of course, spent enormous chunks of time talking about what it all meant for Kansas’ seeding in the tournament. The Jayhawks can’t be a number one, and that was viewed as vital information, as if it made a monumental difference in their NCAA hopes.

Philadelphia Phillies v Miami Marlins
Getty Images
The Week in Sports Pictures

The nation grieved for those hurt, killed and affected by the Boston Marathon bombings. After one of the suspects was caught on Friday — following a day-long lockdown and manhunt — sports returned to Boston over the weekend.

It doesn’t. They can lose as a one seed and win as a four seed. It’s happened before and will again. That’s why they have a tournament – to determine which team by having them actually play each other, not to guess which is best by having semi-famous ex-jocks with expensive haircuts argue about it while I’m just trying to watch the ding-danged game.

So shut up, you make-believe rocket scientists. Quit giving yourselves fancy titles and acting as if any of this actually means anything. Tell me what’s happening, give me some insights into what I’m seeing, and lay off the bracket-babble.

We’ll all know Sunday night who’s in and who’s out and where they’re seeded. For me, that’s soon enough.

© 2013 NBC Sports.com  Reprints

advertisement
More news
NBC Sports
Trickle down

  DPS: Duke coach Mike Krzyzewski admitted that coaching in the Olympics extended his tenure at Duke, saying, “I wouldn’t stop coaching at Duke while I am still the National [team] coach.”

Image: Duke v Louisville
Getty Images
CBT: Coach K to remain at Duke through 2016

CBT: Duke head coach Mike Krzyzewski made it official that he'll be coaching Team USA at the 2016 Rio Olympics, and he'll also be with Duke at least that long, too.

College basketball videos
Team USA prolongs Coach K's tenure at Duke
DPS: Duke coach Mike Krzyzewski joins the Dan Patrick Show to talk about his decision to return as Team USA basketball coach. Coach K admits coaching in the Olympics has extending his tenure at Duke, saying, “I wouldn’t stop coaching at Duke while I am still the National [team] coach.”

Slideshow
Northwestern State v Florida
  Three cheers for college hoops
Take a look at cheerleaders in action from around the country.

NBCSports.com