Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: More heroics from Hamilton as Rangers win 13

'Rougher' than NBA, college game at crossroads

No consensus how to start stemming rash of flagrant fouls, flying elbows

Image: Thabeet, BlairGetty Images
Connecticut's Hasheem Thabeet is pulled over the top of Pittsburgh's DeJuan Blair after vying for a rebound. The play was one of the more notable instances of how physical college basketball has become, writes Ray Glier.

Ray Glier
ATLANTA - College basketball is steaming toward a crossroads. A game once built on speed, passing and quick movement has become bogged down by ever-bigger players focused on physical play.

There have been a rash of flagrant fouls and flying elbows this season, which have caused alarm among NCAA and conference officials. Those elbows, and one notable face stomping, however, are part of the bigger issue of how physical the game has become, particularly in heated conference games.

Don Shea, a regional supervisor of NCAA basketball officials until he retired in 2008, thinks the game has simply become more bruising.

“The college game,” Shea says, “has become rougher than the pro game.”

Shea says that post play has been the focus of college basketball referees for years. The organization has worked to clean up the pushing and hard fouls around the basket. What has happened, he says, is that the game has gotten harder to police inside because of the size of players and a too-narrow foul lane, among other reasons.

The intensity of the post play then infects the rest of the game, Shea says. Pretty soon, tempers are flaring out on the floor, not just under the basket.

Coaches on the sidelines are chirping away at officials and the student sections, at ground level and close to opposing players, are taunting and pouring on more gas. Soon, there is a cauldron.

“It is not just the idea of elbows, it is more along the lines of bumping the cutters, allowing contact on drives. There is way too much of that," says Jay Bilas, an ESPN analyst who played at Duke.

NCAA tournament projections
Who’s dancing next year?
The 2010 men's NCAA tournament’s now complete, so let's turn to next season. We project the field of 64. Where is your team?

NBCSports.com

“It is really hard for teams to run good offense when you get chucked in the middle of a cut. That is going on way too much.”

John Adams, who is in his first season as the NCAA coordinator of officiating, says he has a mandate to promote “freedom of movement” over the old mantra of “advantage, disadvantage,” which most interpreted as if you shoved somebody and it didn’t result in a missed shot or turnover it was OK.

Adams says he wants some uniformity to the game with a series of “absolutes” that don't vary from league to league. For instance, two hands in the back of a dribbler is a foul, whether it is in the Big Ten or the Big East. He wants eight to 10 “absolutes” within the next five years.

“We are trying to move the game to a more graceful, finesse game than it has been in the past,” Adams says. “We recognize it gets too rough. We have created absolutes so all the referee has to do is recognize the play and it is a foul. He doesn’t have to think advantage-disadvantage, north-south, none of that.

“Coaches are for it. That’s where I got the idea.”

As for the physical post play, it has been cleaned up somewhat by natural order: Big men bolt to the NBA, thus there are fewer head-to-head conflicts in the paint.

But when two experienced post players like UConn’s Hasheem Thabeet and Pittsburgh’s DeJuan Blair are together, it can be a testy situation with tempers flaring, which is what happened in a recent Big East game. There was a flock of flying elbows.

Even the game's biggest and strongest players are affected. Consider Oklahoma's Blake Griffin, a 6-10, 250-pound forward. He received six stitches after taking an elbow to the face against Rice, was tripped on a fast break against Utah and punched below the belt against USC. Saturday was another blow, when an elbow to the head against Texas gave Griffin a concussion.

A sampling of rough play in college basketball
?Houston's Aubrey Coleman was suspended one game after stepping on Arizona's Chase Budinger.
?Oklahoma's Blake Griffin received six stitches under his right eye after an elbow in game against Rice. He also suffered a concussion against Texas.
?Michigan's Zack Novak and Manny Harris were ejected from games and Novak suspended for one after elbowing incidents against Ohio State and Purdue, respectively.
?Indiana's Devan Dumes was ejected against Michigan State after he swung his elbow and made contact with Tom Herzog. He was suspended.
?DeQuan Jones of Miami (Fla.) was ejected for a flagrant foul after hitting Duke's Greg Paulus with an elbow.
“The NBA has decided, by edict, that they are going to eliminate rough play and they have and the game is much better to watch,” Bilas says. “It is much easier for the great athletes to get to the basket.”

Florida coach Billy Donovan says there is no question college basketball has become more physical. He thinks officials must find the right balance of calling fouls and just letting players play.

“It is a hard thing to really figure out,” Donovan says. “What you could probably do is have college basketball turn into teams taking 40 and 50 free throws.

“If you go to an international lane and you will get more of a pure game in terms of passing and cutting. But because our lane is narrower than NBA lane it is without question a very hard game to officiate without breaking the flow.”

More on: Rough play | College basketball


advertisement
More news
Image: Drew Gordon, Brandon Hucks
AP
Gordon reacted to article right way

CBT: Drew Gordon is taking a different approach to SI's UCLA article than Reeves Nelson, one much more likely to result in hearing his name called come NBA draft day.

Former Indiana coach Watson dies at 88

BLOOMINGTON, Ind. (AP) - Former Indiana coach and player Lou Watson has died at the age of 88.

Slideshow
Image: NCAA Men's Championship Game - Kansas v Kentucky
  It's Madness time!
See some of the top images from the NCAA men's basketball tournament.

NBCSports.com

College basketball videos
National champion Wildcats visit White House
President Obama welcomes the University of Kentucky men's basketball team to the White House on Friday.

Slideshow
NCAA Basketball Tournament -  Loyola v Ohio State
  Three cheers for college hoops
Take a look at cheerleaders in action from around the country.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image:
  The Week in Sports Pictures
A kayaker flips out, a racehorse eyes the Triple Crown and more.

more photos