updated 9:17 p.m. ET Jan. 28, 2009

WINSTON-SALEM, N.C. - Everybody figured Wake Forest would ask star scorer Jeff Teague to take the shot that would knock off No. 1 Duke. That’s why coach Dino Gaudio instead drew up a play for the player whose defensive lapse let the Blue Devils tie it.

James Johnson made up for a horrible final minute on defense by hitting the layup with 0.8 seconds left that helped the sixth-ranked Demon Deacons upend Duke 70-68 on Wednesday night in a matchup of the two most recent top-ranked teams.

“We knew everybody was going to key on Jeff Teague — he’s the one who scores for us, puts buckets up for us,” Johnson said. “I finished the play.”

And, more importantly, the game. Johnson had 13 points and 11 rebounds and freshman Al-Farouq Aminu finished with 15 points and 10 rebounds for the Demon Deacons (17-1, 4-1 Atlantic Coast Conference).

They bounced back from last week’s home loss that knocked them from No. 1 by forcing the Blue Devils into their worst shooting night of the season and making a statement for a second chance at the top spot.

“Pittsburgh goes down, then we go down, then Duke — I mean, whoever’s No. 1, they’ve got a rude awakening,” Teague said.

Wake Forest led nearly the entire way, before letting a late 13-point lead slip away and recovering just in time to claim the fifth victory over a top-ranked team in school history.

Kyle Singler had 22 points and 12 rebounds for Duke (18-2, 5-1), which had its 10-game winning streak snapped.

“I didn’t think we had the aggressiveness or toughness that we’ve shown. Then, all of a sudden, we had so much of it, it was unbelievable,” Duke coach Mike Krzyzewski said. “Our kids played so hard to put themselves in a position to win.”

Especially Gerald Henderson, who had 20 points — including a jumper over Johnson with 10 seconds left that tied it at 68 and capped the Blue Devils’ late 20-7 rally.

The Demon Deacons raced downcourt, with Teague and Aminu missing layups in traffic — but during the rebound, Henderson was called for traveling. That gave the ball back to Wake Forest with 2.6 seconds left, and L.D. Williams inbounded it under the basket to Johnson, whose layup in the final second banked through to the delight of a juiced-up crowd at Joel Coliseum.

Singler’s full-court inbounds pass for Henderson was tipped by Williams, and that sent Wake Forest’s tie-dye-clad student section spilling onto the court for the second time this month. They whooped it up in similar fashion 2½ weeks ago when they knocked off then-No. 3 North Carolina.

Jon Scheyer had 13 points and David McClure finished with 12 rebounds for Duke, which was playing its first game as No. 1 since 2006 and wound up becoming the latest top-ranked team to fall in Winston-Salem.

“You give our coaching staff a whole week to prepare for you, we’re going to have everything down pat,” Teague said.

He scored 11 points — 10 fewer than his average — on 4-of-14 shooting for the Demon Deacons, who were playing for the first time since a loss to Virginia Tech a week earlier cost them the second No. 1 ranking in school history.

The sophomore point guard — and breakout star — did enough to improve to 2-0 in his career against the Blue Devils. Last season, he scored 26 points in the Demon Deacons’ upset of then-No. 2 Duke. Wake Forest has won five of six meetings at Joel Coliseum.

“I really wasn’t making any shots, but our team scored points,” Teague said. “When you see Duke, you’re always going to step up your game.”

Henderson’s jumper capped a remarkable rally for the Blue Devils, who trailed 61-48 with 8:49 remaining.

“There was a period there when we were going to get blown out of here — not a great night for us,” Krzyzewski said.

That changed because of Singler, who had 10 points during the burst that ended with a flurry in the final seconds.

MORE FROM COLLEGE BASKETBALL

College basketball Section Front

Scramble already underway for big Dance Live: Follow Sunday's college basketball games Wall, Patterson lead No. 4 Kentucky by Rider No. 17 OU falls flat in Capel's return to VCU No caffeine needed by Memphis' energetic Pastner Men’s Top 25 preview, analysis, stats, more Elite scorers, sleeper teams, top conferences, more   Slideshow: College hoops All-American teams SCORES, SCHEDULES, STANDINGS, STATS Odds College basketball Section Front   Add College basketball headlines to your news reader: