Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Adele is big winner, Houston honored at Grammys

What will BCS title game really prove now?

UF or OU No. 1? Well, Utah, USC already proven they'd be worthy champs

AllState Sugar Bowl - Utah v AlabamaGetty Images
Utah No. 1? Why not? After dismantling Alabama in the Sugar Bowl, whose to say the only undefeated team in the country isn't also the best, writes Sporting News columnist Matt Hayes.

Matt Hayes
No matter what you call it or how you see it, there are a whole lot of folks in Salt Lake City begging for a little deductive reasoning.

If A beats B and C beats B worse than A, why isn't C playing for it all?

Or something like that.

"I know where I'm voting us," Utah coach Kyle Whittingham said Friday night to a nationally televised audience after the Utes' 31-17 victory over Alabama in the Sugar Bowl. "I'm voting us No. 1."

Amen, brother.

We've seen three of five BCS games, and it's beginning to look a whole lot like the BCS points series not only whiffed once by not spitting out Rose Bowl champion USC, but may have blown it twice by ignoring unbeaten Utah.

That Florida-Oklahoma national title game is getting more minimized by the moment.

Utah's convincing victory over Alabama — the same Tide team that spent five weeks at No. 1 in the BCS standings before losing in the final week of the season to Florida — will have playoff proponents in full force. Let me explain more steps of deductive reasoning:

• Utah beat Oregon State, which beat USC. Deductive reasoning: Utah would beat USC.

• Ole Miss embarrassed Texas Tech — the same Texas Tech team that Oklahoma uses as its go-to game in its BCS argument. Alabama beat Ole Miss, and we all know Utah dismantled the Tide from the first snap of the Sugar Bowl. Deductive reasoning: Utah would beat Oklahoma.

• And, of course, Utah beat Alabama worse than Florida. Deductive reasoning: Utah would beat Florida.

Before you playoff nuts get all sideways, consider this: The one model that could eventually be agreed upon by the BCS presidents — a plus-one game after the bowls — wouldn't settle this debate. The winner of the Florida-Oklahoma game plays who?

USC, Utah, Texas?

Anyone who says Utah doesn't belong in that argument didn't watch the Sugar Bowl. Exactly which team looked like the SEC team — the team with superior speed and athleticism and desire?

I'm not exactly sure how many third-and-longs Utah made, but it had to be 800. I'm not sure how many times the Utes' quick defensive line beat Alabama's senior-laden tough guys for sacks, but it had to be another 800.

Utah had the two best players on the field (defensive end Paul Kruger and wideout Freddie Brown) and the fire and passion of a championship team. Florida and LSU beat Ohio State in the last two national championship games because the Buckeyes couldn't handle the SEC's speed on the defensive line.

Utah gave the snobby league a taste of the humiliation it has handed out for years — and hopefully forced pollsters to take a second look at non-BCS teams.

That, or use a little deductive reasoning.

© 2012 Sporting News

advertisement
More news
Image: Boston College v Miami
Getty Images
'I'm taking that program down'

Miami coach Al Golden says the worst is behind him, but his headaches figure to continue now that former booster Nevin Shapiro, now in jail, says his involvement with the Hurricanes program will result in stiff penalties.

Image: LSU quarterback Jefferson is stripped of the ball by Alabama's Hightower during the second half of the NCAA BCS National Championship college football game in New Orleans
Reuters
CFT: Jefferson says 'Alabama was more prepared'

CFT: Jordan Jefferson makes it clear he wasn't happy with LSU's game plan in the Tigers' BCS Championship Game loss to Alabama.

Video: Football from NBC Sports
Memphis fulfills BCS dream
Tigers officials thrilled to announce that school has been accepted to join the Big East Conference in 2013.

Slideshow
Image: Joe Paterno
  Joe Paterno (1926-2012)
A look at the career of legendary Penn State coach Joe Paterno

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image:
  BCS title game
Check out photos of Crimson Tide's victory over Tigers.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Kansas State running back Pease is tackled by Arkansas defensive tackle Jones during the Cotton Bowl Classic football game in Arlington, Texas
  Bowled over
Check out the action from the postseason games.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Kansas vs Oklahoma State
  All-American team
Check out which players were best of the best at each position.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Rose Bowl Game presented by Vizio - Wisconsin v Oregon
  College cheer
Check out some of the college football cheerleaders from across the country.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

Video
  Sugar Bowl postgame interviews
Nick Saban makes an apology and Utah's coach Whittingham and QB Brian Johnson think Utah is the best team in the country.