There were 64,185 fans in Yankee Stadium on Dec. 28, not even a sellout — despite a healthy contingent of Colts fans who had made the four-hour train journey up from Baltimore.

After the turnover-plagued start, Unitas hit Moore for 60 yards, setting up the Colts at the New York 25.

But Steve Myhra, who had made just four of 10 field goals in the regular season, missed a 32-yard field goal and then had one blocked by Huff after the Giants were offside on the first attempt.

On the next drive, Gifford’s 38-yard run set up Summerall’s 36-yard field goal to give the Giants a 3-0 lead with 2:02 left in the first quarter.

For most of the next two periods, Baltimore dominated.

Gifford’s fumble at his 18 set up Baltimore’s first TD, a 2-yard run by Ameche.

After Jackie Simpson fumbled Don Chandler’s punt to give the Giants the ball at the Colts 10, Gifford gave it right back, Don Joyce recovering at the 14. “Not my greatest game,” Gifford says now. “I fumbled going out and I fumbled going in.”

Unitas then drove Baltimore 86 yards, finding Berry from 15 yards and the Colts led 14-3 at the half.

Baltimore seemed ready to put the game away midway through the third quarter, driving to a first down at the Giants 3.

The Colts were stuffed on three straight plays, then went for it on fourth-and-goal from the 1. Unitas called a halfback pass by Ameche, who was to toss the ball to Jim Mutscheller.

The pass call was prefaced by a “P” when Unitas called it. Ameche didn’t hear that and was buried at the 5 by linebacker Cliff Livingston while Mutscheller stood alone in the end zone.

That awakened the Giants.

Two plays later, Charley Conerly found Kyle Rote behind the Baltimore secondary. He raced to the Colts 25, where Andy Nelson knocked the ball loose. But New York’s Alex Webster scooped it up and took it to the 1, setting up Mel Triplett’s TD run that made it 14-10.

On New York’s next possession, the Giants took a 17-14 lead on a 15-yard Conerly-to-Gifford pass that followed passes of 17 and 46 yards to Bob Schnelker. The stadium rocked.

The score stayed that way deep into the final period.

With 2:40 left, the Giants had a third-and-4 from their 40 and Gifford swept right, diving for the first-down marker. Marchetti pulled him down and 6-foot-6, 285-pound Gene “Big Daddy” Lipscomb, landed on Marchetti’s ankle, breaking it. As Marchetti was treated and taken off the field — he lay on a stretcher on the sideline to watch the finish — the ball lay where Gifford had left it. Then referee Ron Gibbs picked it up and spotted it several inches back, just short of a first down.

Gifford still insists he made it.

Asked what might have happened if there had been instant replay, he laughs and replies: “We wouldn’t be here.” His teammates concur; the Colts don’t, and history records him as short.

So New York punted and Unitas and Berry put on a show that made the game into the “Greatest Game.”

Starting from his 14, Unitas hit Moore for 11 yards, then Berry for 25, 15, and 22. On came Myhra, who hit from 19 with 7 seconds left as the Colts and their fans held their breath.

Overtime.

“We really didn’t know what to do,” Berry says. “We’d never played it. Nobody had ever played it. Nobody really knew what came next.”

What came next was a coin flip. The Giants won but came up a yard short again on third down. They punted.

That was it. Unitas toyed with New York’s exhausted defense. L.G. Dupre ran for 11, Unitas hit Berry for 21, Ameche ran for 22 and Unitas hit Berry again for 12 yards to the 8, within easy field goal range.

Legend has it that Colts owner Carroll Rosenbloom had bet thousands of dollars on his team, which was favored by anywhere from 3½ to 5½ points. But the players insisted that because Myhra was unreliable, they went for the TD.

So Unitas passed to Mutscheller to the 1 and Ameche ran it in as fans swarmed the field.

The Colts and Giants simply went to the locker rooms, talked to the media and left — the Giants for homes all over the country, the Colts for a short flight to Baltimore, where 30,000 people met their plane. None thought about history.

MORE FROM NFL

NFL Section Front

Colts, Saints not about to lose now   PFTV: Can the Saints go 16-0 this season?   Video: Saints ‘trying to give back,’ Brees says   PFT: Sharper returns for Saints   PFT: Cribbs active for Browns, one week after injury   PFT: Winfield out for Vikings vs. Seahawks PFT: Saints’ Bush, Ellis out vs. Bucs PFT: Holmgren back to Seahawks in front office? Polamalu could miss three games PFT: Shanahan interested in Cowboys, Redskins, Texans? NFL Section Front   Add NFL headlines to your news reader: