Skip navigation

Minaya's task: Find Mets their Brad Lidge

If closer had been in New York, Mets might be champions

Image: Lidge
Chris O'meara / AP
Brad Lidge was perfect for the Phillies in save situations in 2008. The Mets were not nearly as fortunate.
Midseason report
MLB's midseason report
Can the Cubs rally to make playoffs? Team-by-team predictions
Video: Baseball from NBC Sports
Nomar returns to Boston
July 7: Nomar Garciaparra says coming back to Fenway and receiving an enthusiastic welcome was extremely special.

OPINION
By Richard Justice
updated 1:09 a.m. ET Nov. 11, 2008

One thing separated the Mets and Phillies last season. Actually, it was one person.

Brad Lidge.

Everything the Mets do this offseason should be geared toward finding someone to do for them what Brad Lidge did for the Phillies in 2008.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

As far as offseason goals go, that's about as simple as it gets. The Mets may need tweaking in other areas, but until their single glaring weakness is fixed, those other things won't matter.

Here's an idea: Mets GM Omar Minaya should display a large photo of Lidge somewhere in his office and be forced to look at it first thing every morning.

He should make Lidge the background on his desktop and wear a Brad Lidge locket around his neck.

Minaya can't take his eye off the ball. He should be reminded again and again that the Phillies couldn't have won without Lidge. Had he pitched for the Mets, they might be the ones being measured for rings.

So when Francisco Rodriguez asks for an astronomical amount of money, Minaya should think long and hard about Brad Lidge before he answers.

Likewise, if the Mariners want too much for J.J. Putz, Minaya should remind himself of how Lidge transformed the Phillies.

Check out the numbers. The Mets and Phillies each scored 799 runs. Pretty close, right?

The Mets had a better rotation. Their starters had a lower ERA. They got more innings and more victories from their rotation than the Phillies did.

But the Mets had 14 more blown saves than the Phillies. Mets relievers made good on 60 percent of their save chances; the Phillies converted 76 percent.

The Phillies didn't lose a game in which they led after eight innings. The Mets lost seven times when leading after the eighth.

Whatever chance the Mets had of winning the National League East probably ended when Billy Wagner pitched his final game on August 2.

Mets manager Jerry Manuel did a nice job mixing and matching his relievers for a while, but by those final three weeks, the bullpen was a disaster with an ERA approaching six.

Manuel was using three and four relievers to finish almost every game. And it wasn't nearly enough.

Mets fans are focused on Minaya making wholesale changes. They want to see no more of Aaron Heilman, Duaner Sanchez, Pedro Feliciano, etc.

They're missing the big picture. If Minaya acquires a closer, all those pitchers will assume other roles.

They've all had success in non-closing roles and might still be valuable in those roles.

There's a practical side to this as well. Minaya can't replace everyone. He still has almost his entire bullpen for relatively little money for another year.

He shouldn't stop with K-Rod. Let's face it, he's not limited by finances the way other general managers are.

The Mets may talk about fiscal responsibility, but in the end, they've got the resources to turn a weakness into a strength.

Doug Brocail and Russ Springer are both free agents. So are Bob Howry, Shawn Chacon and Darren Oliver.

Signing a first-rate closer is expensive, but filling in quality pieces in front of the closer isn't.

The Mets have had two embarrassing September meltdowns. There have been problems beyond the bullpen, but this season's problems began with the bullpen.

Now about Francisco Rodriguez. He's just 26 years old. He converted 62 of 69 save chances in 2008.

Slide show
Image: Spanish bullfighter Jose Tomas is tossed by a bull during a bullfight at Monumental bullring in Barcelona
  The Week in Sports Pictures
Fireworks, crash landings, Wimbledon theatrics and more.

more photos

Last season was the first time he has made more than 69 appearances, so he should have more good years left in him.

He appears to have the temperament to thrive in the fishbowl that is New York, which is not like other places. Losses are magnified. Tabloids feed off slumps.

That's probably more true for a closer than any other position in the city, except for maybe the quarterbacks of the Jets and Giants.

Rodriguez has 208 career saves. He has pitched in a World Series at 20 and has been to the postseason four other times. He's accustomed to pitching with a lot on the line.

In the end, it's just money. It'll be a lot of money. Lidge's three-year, $37.5-million deal with the Phillies will be a starting point.

It's worth it. No number is too high. Not when you consider what the Mets have been through the last two years, not when you consider how he would turn a weakness into a strength.

Minaya's work won't be finished after he finds a closer, but the transformation of the Mets will have begun.

© 2009 The Sporting News

Sponsored links