Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Mickelson a marvel at Pebble Beach, while Tiger tumbles

Heartbreaking defeats nothing new to Irish

ND's 4 OT loss to Pitt is just another in a long line of crushing losses

LeSean McCoyAP
Pittsburgh running back LeSean McCoy rushed for 169 yards in a 4OT win over the Irish.

The dazzling freshman from St. Paul had a career-high 10 catches and two touchdown receptions in the loss. He will likely need only three seasons to break the Irish career receiving records (receptions, yardage, touchdowns) that the Shark set earlier this decade. Then again, Samardzija really did all his work in just two seasons.

But then the Irish began to unravel. Samardzija surely recognized that as well. Afterward, head coach Charlie Weis said, “I could give you 50 plays that would have been the difference between winning and losing.”

That may be hyperbole, but we can give you five. The first, and what may not be remembered as the most important though it should be, is the 15-yard personal foul penalty accrued by linebacker Harrison Smith early in the second half. At the time, Notre Dame held a comfortable 17-3 lead and all of the game’s momentum. Pitt took the second half kickoff and meekly gained six yards on three plays.

However, after the third down play was whistled dead, Smith, an aggressive defender, took it upon himself to push a Pitt tight end to the ground from behind.

“Well, that was the one I was talking about,” Weis said afterward, referring to plays that altered the course of this game. “I never saw it, but the ref came over and said, ‘Coach, it was blatant.’”

Which it was.

More than 27 minutes remained in the game when that play occurred — the Irish would allow three fourth-down conversions on three separate touchdown drives in the aftermath — but it resuscitated an until-then moribund Panther offense. Pitt happily accepted the second chance Smith’s moment of immaturity afforded them and five plays later scored.

Suddenly, it was just a one-touchdown game. And that creeping feeling, the one that suggests that a Notre Dame home game will not be decided until the final minute … if not one, two, three…four overtimes later, had returned.

These paroxysms of self-defeating defeatism were prevalent before Weis arrived in 2005. Still, the Irish are now 0-3 under him in overtime (and today it was hard to blame the kicker, Brandon Walker, who nailed three of four, including a 48-yarder, in overtime). And, while Pitt currently resides just on the wrong side of the border of the A.P. poll, it is worth noting that the Irish are 1-6 in their last seven games versus ranked opponents.

The Irish, now 5-3, are certainly improved from a year ago. But, in two of their last three games they’ve had double-digit leads late in the second quarter only to lose. What could easily be a 7-1 Irish team headed to a sunny bowl game is now just a 5-3 squad, slightly above average.

Somewhere, Mark May is gloating. And that somewhere is within three feet of Lou Holtz.

Dave Wannstedt made his debut as Pittsburgh’s head coach on the same evening, in the same game, as Charlie Weis did at Notre Dame. The Irish won that game handily, and Weis has had more success in terms of number of wins than Wannstedt has.

However Pitt, under Wannstedt, has beaten top-15 opponents. Last December, the Panthers won at West Virginia, denying the Mountaineers a spot in the BCS championship game. Earlier this season they upended unbeaten, then-No. 13 South Florida in Tampa.

More than three and a half seasons into Weis’s tenure in South Bend, the Irish still lack a signature win. They beat the sub-.500 schools whom they are supposed to wallop, lie supine versus elite programs, and suffer gut-punch defeats to teams who will find themselves playing bowl games in December.

They are so maddeningly predictable. A loss at Chestnut Hill next week should follow, then a pair of wins versus Navy and Syracuse, culminating in a 31-point loss at USC on Thanksgiving weekend.

You think back to three Octobers earlier, to a student section that rushed the playing field when it initially appeared that time had expired, the scoreboard reading “Notre Dame 31, USC 28.”

That exuberant mob was ushered off the field. They watched in despair as Matt Leinart fell into the end zone and snuffed out their joy. They’ve been waiting for a moment such as that ever since. The difference is that now, in the waning moments (or overtime) of nip-and-tuck battles, as you stare toward the sea of standing students in the stadium’s northwest corner, it isn’t excitement that you read on Domers’ faces.

It’s dread.

More from John Walters

© 2012 NBC Sports.com  Reprints


< Prev | 1 | 2

advertisement
More news
Navy v Notre Dame
Getty Images
Gray believes in Kelly

It took a while for the light bulb to go on, but when it did, Jonas Gray finally showed the talent many had expected from the blue-chip prospect from Detroit. In a recent interview, Gray, who is rehabbing an ACL injury to get ready for the NFL Scouting Combine, expressed the confidence and support he has for head coach Brian Kelly.

Video
  Heartbreaker in South Bend
Nov. 1: Look back at the highlights from Pitt's 36-33 4OT win over Notre Dame.
Video
  Fragile mindset
Nov. 1: Charlie Weis says he's more worried about his team's psyche than anything else after the 4OT loss to Pitt.
Slideshow
Tyler Eifert , Nigel Bradham
  Notre Dame's 2011 season
Check out some of the best images from Notre Dame's 2011 season.

NBCSports.com

Timeline
Michigan v Notre Dame
Notre Dame 2011 schedule
See when all the big matchups will take place with Notre Dame's 2011 schedule.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Stanford v Notre Dame
  Meet the 2011 Irish
Take a look at some of the key contributors for Notre Dame this season
Slideshow
Discover Orange Bowl - Stanford v Virginia Tech
  2011 Notre Dame opponents
Take a look at some of the key players the Irish will face this season
Slideshow
Image: Rose Bowl Game presented by Vizio - Wisconsin v Oregon
  College cheer
Check out some of the college football cheerleaders from across the country.

NBCSports.com

Special feature
USC v Notre Dame
Irish pride
Check out some of Notre Dame's cheerleaders throughout the years.
Special feature
USC v Notre Dame
Notre Dame Nation
Take a look at the Fighting Irish faithful cheering on Notre Dame.
Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos