Can’t you guys ease up on the bad news?

John W. Schoen Senior producer • Profile • E-mail

Our story last week on the cloudy outlook for housing prices drew heavy reader response with a theme that has become a common thread lately. "If you guys just stop reporting bad news," the theory goes, "wouldn’t that help the economy and housing market get back on its feet?"

I believe that there has been enough hype about the housing crisis. I humbly request that you and your colleagues please stop fueling panic and chase a different story. ... Our economy is based on people spending money, and they are not going to do it if the media keeps hyping the economic downturn.
— T.J. E. San Diego

Has the media ever thought about not just reporting about the doom and gloom of the average house market that does nothing but scares the average Joe and his wife from buying or selling? … If the media would report for just ONE WEEK how good and strong the market is bouncing back, I'll bet the market would see a jump in the right direction.
— Eric M., Address withheld

If you really want things to get better, shouldn't you quit writing stories that feed on the paranoia that is helping create this downward spiral? … You know sometimes all we have is a hope for a better tomorrow because our reality today is not so good. I hope you choose to foster hope, not fear, in the future.
— Joe M., Address withheld

There’s no question that the news these days has put American consumers in a gloomy mood.

Consumer confidence perked up a bit this month from 28-year lows after the government mailed out over $100 billion in rebate checks, but spending is expected to remain tight into next year.

Answer Desk readers aren’t the only ones who blame the media for putting consumers in a bad mood. In his recent remarks about America becoming a “nation of whiners,” former senator (and now former McCain economic adviser) Phil Gramm described the current economy as a “mental recession."

“'Misery sells newspapers,'” he told the Washington Times. "'Thank God the economy is not as bad as you read in the newspaper every day.'"

Based on our mail, msnbc.com readers seem content to make up their own minds based on what they read. There’s a fairly wide variety of opinion about the way the media, this site and this column cover the economy.

For every complaint about “too much bad news” we hear from another reader who wants to know why we’re not reporting the "obvious" financial Armageddon that is so clearly upon us.

According to these readers, those of us in the mainstream media are dodging the “real story” when we report that the official government data show the gross domestic product still advancing (though at a crawl), consumer inflation relatively tame by historical standards (though rising) and the reason why the economy is not “officially” in a recession.

(By the way, could someone shoot us that list of of who just who is and isn't officially part of the MSM? We can't seem to find it.)

Those are the facts. You can check them out at for yourself at several government Web sites, including www.bls.gov. We’ll leave for another day the debate over whether the government is secretly massaging the numbers to make things look better than they really are.

In any case, whether media coverage of the economy is too rosy, too gloomy or just right is beside the point. If a family is having trouble paying the bills because food and energy prices are rising faster than their paycheck, they’re going to have trouble paying the bills no matter what they read on the Web or see on TV.

If you lose your jobs and can’t pay the mortgage, a story about how things are finally getting better isn’t going to change your financial situation. If we stopped reporting that banks are losing tens of billions of dollars, it wouldn’t make it any easier for you to get a loan. Consumers and businesses experience economic conditions first-hand, not through media coverage.

If the economy has hit a bad patch, trying to turn things around with stories about how great things are would only make matters worse. For one thing, if news sites announced that they had handing out rose-colored glasses to the staff, how would you be able to make rational decisions about spending and investing?

Worse, whether you believe the current economy is in recession or just crawling along slowly, the only way to get things back on track is to find solutions to the problems that are weighing on the housing market, the financial system and the broader economy. And the only way to find those solutions is with a clear-eyed, level-headed look at those problems.

MORE FROM ANSWER DESK

Answer Desk Section Front

Answer Desk: Uncle Sam's borrowing binge Answer Desk: Questions we missed in 2008 Why can't I get zero-interest loans? The $8 trillion question Stopping the recession Explaining the oil bust Cash out my 401(K) or hang on? The debt legacy Time to end oil tax breaks? A 401(k) urban legend Answer Desk Section Front   Add Answer Desk headlines to your news reader: