updated 1:51 a.m. ET June 13, 2008

SAN DIEGO - Tiger Woods grimaced and pursed his lips, unable to disguise the pain Thursday in the U.S. Open.

No, it wasn’t his left knee, though that was still tender from surgery.

It was the three-putt to end his round at Torrey Pines, leaving him four shots behind a pair of surprising leaders and one behind Phil Mickelson.

Nothing torments Woods more than that.

He expected soreness in his knee. He didn’t expect his first double bogey in 416 holes.

What no one saw coming — certainly not the gallery that stood a dozen deep to watch the All-Star pairing of Woods and Mickelson — was Kevin Streelman and Justin Hicks tied for the lead at 3-under 68.

“To make two double bogeys and a three-putt and only be four back, that’s a great position to be in,” Woods said after his 1-over 72, “because I know I can clean that up tomorrow.”

The leaders have some history at Torrey Pines that takes some explaining.

Streelman was an unknown rookie when he got into the Buick Invitational in January as the third alternate and wound up in the final group with Woods in the third round. His world ranking was No. 1,354, and he closed with rounds of 75-77 to slip back into oblivion until he emerged anew at Torrey Pines this week.

“I do enjoy this golf course,” Streelman said.

Hicks played at the Buick Invitational, too — but it wasn’t the same guy whose name was atop the leaderboard of the U.S. Open. Turns out there’s another Justin Hicks, a club pro in San Diego, who qualified for the PGA Tour event. He showed up in the gallery to watch Justin Hicks, the Nationwide Tour player, fire off six birdies on his opening nine and hold it together.

“A lot of weird stuff going on out there today,” Hicks said.

That includes the star pairing of Woods and Mickelson that brought enormous crowds outside the ropes and more than 100 media inside the ropes. Woods made his first double bogey since September, worked his way onto the leaderboard and then made another.

Mickelson, the guy who carried two drivers in his bag at the Masters when he won his first major, didn’t have any in his bag for the U.S. Open. He still managed to reach both par 5s on the back in two, both times settling for birdie on his way to a 71.

“I felt like with the fairways being firm like they were today, all I needed was a 3-wood,” Mickelson said.

Stranger still was the eclectic mix of players who managed to break par.

Video   Tiger's first round June 12: Swing by swing of Tiger Woods' first day at the 2008 U.S. Open. NBC Sports

Hicks is No. 722 in the world ranking, tied with Streelman, who is No. 608. Right behind was Eric Axley (No. 503), who has bittersweet memories of this place. His caddie, Steve DuPlantis, was killed by a car while crossing the street at the Buick Invitational. He shot 69 and was tied with Stuart Appleby, Rocco Mediate and former U.S. Open champion Geoff Ogilvy.

Two-time U.S. Open champion Ernie Els was among 11 players who managed to break par at Torrey Pines, the public golf course along the bluffs of the Pacific that held its own. A year ago at Oakmont, only two players broke par in the opening round.

Even so, the focus was on Woods and Mickelson, playing together in a U.S. Open for the first time since 1999.

MORE FROM GOLF

Golf Section Front

Ochoa edges Shin for LPGA's top player award Nordqvist wins LPGA Tour Championship Out of Bounds: Tiger booed ... at Stanford? Latest golf videos Latest player news, rumors and more Tracking Tiger: News, features and more Tiger's triumphs: Recapping all Woods' wins Vote: When will Tiger win his 15th major? Vote, discuss: Best major of 2009? Special section: Golf on NBC   Golf Section Front   Add Golf headlines to your news reader: