Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: More heroics from Hamilton as Rangers win 13

Better than MJ? Kobe enters the debate

Beating Celtics, adding more titles could put Bryant ahead of Jordan

Image: Kobe BryantAP
The greatest ever? Kobe Bryant just might be heading in that direction.

Michael Ventre
Over the years, Michael Jordan comparisons have been as frequent as Shaquille O’Neal misses at the free throw line. It seems every Tom, Dick, Harry and Kobe who comes along inspires the old, “Is he the next Jordan?” cacophony. It’s almost as if people weren’t happy enough with the first Jordan, so they embark on a crusade to find a new one.

There is no “next Jordan.” There is, and always will be, just one. He won six championships. He was a middling outfielder in double A. He yelled at Kwame Brown a lot.

But what about Jordan’s title of “Greatest Player Ever”? Is that up for debate? Time marches on, and memories fade. All of a sudden, Jordan’s accomplishments are but a dim memory, trotted out occasionally in highlight form, while present-day hot shots vie to fill his hallowed high tops.

It’s hard to say at this moment in history that Kobe Bryant has supplanted Jordan as “The Greatest Player Ever,” for a variety of reasons. Yet would it be sacrilege to suggest that, if the guy leads these Los Angeles Lakers past the Boston Celtics in the 2008 NBA Finals, he at least belongs in the discussion?

Would that be hardwood heresy?

I think not.

Right now, Jordan’s grip on the moniker is secure, despite the passage of time as well as a failure of stewardship with the Washington Wizards and a “The jury is still out, but leaning toward conviction” stint with the Charlotte Bobcats.

The man led the Chicago Bulls to six championships. He was impossible to guard. His game matured with each passing season. He set a standard of excellence in practice that kept his teammates from settling for less. And he was as clutch a performer as there ever has been.

Yes, his legend was enhanced greatly by the marketing campaigns that hitched a ride on his basketball star. He certainly was a brand unto himself, and the advertising of his shoes served to trumpet the individual as well.

But he’s still The Man among the basketball cognoscenti. His reputation as a player has staying power.

Kobe’s case to be included as a candidate is complicated. It involves basketball and personal issues. There are probably as many character witnesses in his corner as there are detractors. And much of the anti-Kobe sentiment is the result of his own actions and behavior.

In hoop terms, Bryant is probably as spectacular in every phase of the game as Jordan ever was. He can drive to the hoop in the most daunting of circumstances and finish with the same acrobatic flourish as the former Bulls’ star. He can nail outside shots under duress, with the final seconds of a game ticking away and his team behind, and like Jordan he does so as if he’s playing HORSE in the backyard.

After a long struggle with questionable basketball judgment, he is finally making the kinds of decisions that Jordan used to make. Kobe rarely makes a dumb play these days, and this season he almost never has gone one-against-three when there are open teammates waiting for the ball. He’s a tenacious defender and a great leader.

Kobe has a lot more baggage. The days feuding with Shaq. The Colorado incident. The occasional tantrums. The scheme to have owner Jerry Buss cowtow to his every whim before he would sign a new contract. And, of course, the “Trade me” tirade of last spring.

But really, none of that works against him as much as this:

Jordan has six rings. Kobe only has three.

In this American sporting society, it’s all about the hardware. Joe Montana is clearly a better quarterback than Troy Aikman, because Montana has four rings and Aikman only three. Forget the many variables that should also be involved — the levels of competition, the coaching staffs, the supporting casts, injuries, etc. — what people want to know is, “How many championships?”


advertisement
More news
Image: 76ers vs. Celtics, Game 7
Getty Images
Survival of the fittest

LIVE: The Boston Celtics and Philadelphia 76ers are playing in Game 7 for a berth into the Eastern Conference finals where the winner will face the Miami Heat.

Miami Heat v Indiana Pacers - Game Six
NBC Sports
SportsTalk: Do Heat actually want Celtics?

  SportsTalk: Who do the Heat really want to play in the Eastern Conference finals?

  ProBasketballTalk tweets

  1. Loading the latest posts…

Source: Twitter. For more, follow @basketballtalk.

  Ask the NBA expert: Ira Winderman

Do you have a burning NBA question? Submit it now, and then check back for our reader mailbag.

Slideshow
Philadelphia 76ers v Boston Celtics - Game Five
  Celebs shine at NBA playoffs
A look at the many celebrities who made appearances during this year's NBA playoffs.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Miami Heat v Indiana Pacers - Game Six
  Pictures of the postseason
Check out some of the best images from the 2012 NBA playoffs.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Minnesota Timberwolves v Detroit Pistons
  Get your cheer on
Check out some of the dancers from the NBA.

more photos

Special feature
Dennis Johnson, Earvin Magic Johnson
Rivalry renewed
The Lakers and Cetics are meeting for the 11th time in NBA Finals history.

NBCSports.com

Special feature
Where are they now?
NBCSports.com spills the whereabouts of past Celtics and Lakers stars.

NBCSports.com

Slide show
Boston Celtics v Detroit Pistons, Game 6
The second season
Slide show: Top images from the 2008 NBA playoffs.

NBCSports.com