Skip navigation

Two nights, two blown calls: Time for replay?

Deep in tradition, baseball remains only pro sport not to use video review

Cubs Astros Baseball
Chicago's Aramis Ramirez (16), Geovany Soto (18) and Kosuke Fukudome head to the dugout after scoring on Soto's three-run homer in the fourth inning against the Houston Astros on Monday.
Pat Sullivan / AP
Midseason report
MLB's midseason report
Can the Cubs rally to make playoffs? Team-by-team predictions
Slideshow
Philadelphia Phillies v New York Yankees
  Who's hot on Twitter?
Check out which of your favorite athletes have the best pages and most followers!

NBCSports.com

Video: Baseball from NBC Sports
Philadelphia Phillies Introduce Pedro Martinez
Getty Images
Pedro: 'I'm a little out there'
July 15: Pedro Martinez is looking forward to the Phillies fans because they're crazy, and he's a little crazy too.

Slide show
Image: Johnny Magallon, Jorge Luis Garces
  The Week in Sports Pictures
Manny messes up, the Tour takes off to Spain, Nomar returns and more.

more photos

updated 8:08 p.m. ET May 20, 2008

Chipper Jones has seen enough. Now he wants baseball to take a closer look — at instant replay.

“Anything to get calls right,” the Atlanta star said Tuesday.

A lot of fans are saying the same thing after umpires botched a pair of home-run rulings on national TV.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

On Sunday night, umps at Yankee Stadium reversed their correct call and concluded a shot by Carlos Delgado of the Mets was foul. On Monday night, umps in Houston mistakenly ruled a ball off a center-field wall was in play, prompting a reconfiguration at Minute Maid Park the next day.

The NFL, NBA, NHL, some NCAA sports and major tennis tournaments all use a form of replay. Baseball has resisted a switch, worried it would become too pervasive and further bog down games.

Then there’s tradition. Always a sticking point for the national pastime.

“What makes the game good is the human element of it. The mistakes. Like the strike zone,” Mets reliever Billy Wagner said. “Those are human decisions. If it’s right or wrong, you just go with it.”

Last November, general managers voted 25-5 to try replay on boundary calls — whether possible homers are fair or foul, if balls actually clear fences, whether there’s fan interference.

“I voted for it at every general manager’s meeting since it first came up,” Chicago White Sox GM Kenny Williams said.

“I hope people are taking notice. It’s a different age. The review process on any disputed calls will take much less time than some of these arguments. Everyone should have a vested interest in getting the call right.”

The recommendation went to commissioner Bud Selig, but had no binding effect or time frame. Nor did it include an idea on how to use it: Do teams get to challenge or do umpires decide?

“The commissioner has taken it under advisement,” spokesman Rich Levin said Tuesday.

Selig has never favored replay.

“The commissioner is not a fan of it,” baseball executive Bob Watson said in Houston. “He calls instant replay umpires getting together and trying to get the call right. That is instant replay in his estimation.”

Still, many in baseball believe that replay could get a trial in the next year or two, possibly during spring training or in the minors.

“We’d be all in favor of listening to whatever proposals they might have,” veteran ump John Hirschbeck, president of the umpires’ union, told The Associated Press on Tuesday.

To them, a big problem is the trend of new ballparks with quirky dimensions, odd angles and yellow lines. Gone are the days when balls that cleared the fences were homers, balls that bounced back were all-you-can-get.

“One of the things that they talk about in stadiums nowadays is fan appeal, and fan appeal means trouble for umpires,” Hirschbeck said. “For years, we’ve said, if you want to make it simple, put a basket just like the Cubs have. It would make our lives a lot easier.”

“They want to have all these cuts and different things in the outfield wall. It makes it next to impossible. You can run out as far as you can run. You can be set and staring right at it, and people don’t realize it’s still very, very difficult to tell. One split second that ball touches somewhere and you try to take a mental picture, but it’s very difficult,” he said.

That’s what happened on the ball that Geovany Soto of the Cubs hit Monday night at Houston. Funny thing, he wound up with an inside-the-park home run.


Sponsored links