CINCINNATI - A year ago, it was unthinkable.

Fans were invited recently to exchange their Chad Johnson jerseys for minor league hockey tickets. Nineteen fans accepted the offer, and another gladly relinquished a Chad bobblehead.

A small number, of course. But the fact that anyone would even think of holding such a promotion underscores how far Johnson's image has slipped in the last few months.

"We're trying to raise awareness of ourselves,'' said Cincinnati Cyclones publicity director John Hamel. "Certainly now he's a huge target and the center of discussion here in Cincinnati. What better way to tie ourselves to it?''

Johnson has changed from the Cincinnati Bengals' most beloved player into their most divisive one. Fans have chosen sides on whether he should stay or go. And what he does next will have major repercussions on not only his team's season, but a lot of long-term reputations.

If it turns into a case of Chad Johnson vs. the Cincinnati Bengals, no one wins.

First, a little history.

When the Bengals reworked his contract in April 2006 — coming off their first winning season since 1990 — everyone was delighted. Johnson got an additional $10.75 million in a deal that runs through 2010, with a club option for 2011. The team expected to be back in the playoffs year after year.

Two years later, they're at an ugly impasse.

Johnson's blowup at quarterback Carson Palmer during a loss to New England became the signature moment of a 7-9 season. For the first time in his career, Johnson came under public criticism.

He couldn't deal with it.

Johnson loves attention — it's almost like an addiction — and couldn't understand why fans were suddenly turned off by his look-at-me antics while the team was losing.

Special feature Undrafted? Not a problem Special feature: LSU's Ali Highsmith one of 10 players who could thrive in the NFL despite not being drafted. NBCSports.com

"I'm the type that I want everyone to like me and what I do,'' Johnson said in a 2006 interview. "I don't want anybody to have any doubts in anything that I do.''

Johnson brooded and stopped talking to the local media. In the offseason, he has taken an increasingly harsher stance during a series of national interviews. He threatened to sit out the season if the Bengals didn't trade him. Agent Drew Rosenhaus pleaded with the team to deal him on draft day.

Not a chance.

Philosophically, the Bengals were not about to let a player take all his upfront money and run after only two seasons. Cincinnati ownership has a history of digging in when a recalcitrant player tries to manipulate a trade.

There was a practical reason, too. No. 3 receiver Chris Henry was released after his fifth arrest, leaving the team with only Johnson and T.J. Houshmandzadeh as proven receivers.

If they had accepted Washington's offer of a first-round draft pick and another conditional pick for Johnson, the Bengals would have been writing off next season. A team with only one proven receiver isn't going to win many games.

So, what now?

MORE FROM NFL

NFL Section Front

NFLPA reportedly ready to oust director Upshaw Ease up, Goodell Randy Moss buys a NASCAR truck team Curran: NFL coaches on the hot seat in 2008 Favre says reports of comeback 'all rumor' Curran's blog: Favre story won't fade away Opinion: It's time for Cardinals to stick with Leinart NFL Rumors: Cooley opens his own eBay store   Fantasy Fix video: Still 'Super' Chargers? Latest NFL videos NFL Section Front   Add NFL headlines to your news reader: