Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: 9 die in Kosovo avalanche; child survives

Some race fans call Eight Belles' death 'a fluke'

Churchill Downs patrons says uproar over filly's demise is overblown

Special feature
Eight Belles
Track tragedy
Looking back at Eight Belles' race, tragic demise at the Kentucky Derby.

LOUISVILLE, Ky. - Frank Daniels stood outside the paddock at Churchill Downs on Wednesday, thinking about the first race of the day while watching a rebroadcast of the Kentucky Derby on a big screen.

Daniels is a racing fan who’s been coming to Churchill Downs for 35 years. His eyes stayed fixed as Big Brown surged to victory. A split second later, filly Eight Belles followed, storming to the finish 4¾ lengths behind but well ahead of the remaining 18 colts.

“She didn’t look hurt, did she,” Daniels said. “That’s a strong-looking horse right there.”

What the replay didn’t show, or anyone could have guessed as she lunged for the wire under jockey Gabriel Saez, is that Eight Belles would be dead a quarter-mile later after breaking both of her front legs as she galloped out.

She was quickly was euthanized on the track, tempering Big Brown’s dominant win and raising questions on everything from the safety of the dirt at Churchill Downs to whether Saez abused Eight Belles with his whip in the dash to the wire.

Daniels rolls his eyes at the controversy. He’s seen a lot of racing and a handful of injured horses put down on the track. He considers what happened to Eight Belles an accident.

“It was just a freak thing,” he said. “When you have people like (veterinarian) Larry Bramlage saying they’ve never seen anything like that in their career, it just shows you how odd it really is.”

While saddened by Eight Belles’ tragic end and empathetic for trainer Larry Jones — himself a Kentuckian — many patrons said the furor over her death is overblown.

“It wasn’t the track; it wasn’t the breeding,” Brian Johnston said. “It was a fluke. The people who are talking are people who don’t watch it all year. This is a part of racing. If they want to try and make it safer, I’m all for it, but this wasn’t anybody’s fault.”

Though the Kentucky Derby Museum has received a handful of letters and a flower arrangement in support of Eight Belles, there hasn’t been the kind of overwhelming response to her death that accompanied 2006 Kentucky Derby winner Barbaro’s injury in the Preakness.

The fans at Churchill Downs on Wednesday already appeared to have moved on. There wasn’t an Eight Belles hat or pin to be seen in the modest crowd of a few thousand, though there were more than a few Big Brown hats scattered about the grandstand.

Barbaro’s remains will be buried outside Gate 1 at Churchill Downs. Plans to honor Eight Belles at the track have not been completed with owner Rick Porter, spokesman Darren Rogers said. The track is forwarding most of its well-wishes to Delaware Park in Wilmington, Del., at Jones’ request. The Derby museum is passing along cards to Fox Hill Farms in Lexington, which is owned Porter.

“She really touched a lot of people, I think, because she’s a filly,” museum spokeswoman Wendy Treinen said. “But with Barbaro, he had eight months after he was hurt where his battle was chronicled. This was just so sudden.”

While the questions will linger, the racing will go on.

© 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

advertisement
More news
Image: John Velazquez rides Animal Kingdom to victory during the 137th Kentucky Derby
AP
'All Others' a strong favorite?

The first of three pools of the Kentucky Derby Future Wager begins its three-day run on Friday and the bet's opening scenario is very similar to each of its opening pools since the wager was created in 1999.

Image: 2011 Breeders' Cup World Championships - Day 2
Getty Images
Breeders' Cup returns to NBC

It's first time that Classic will be broadcast in primetime on Nov. 3.

Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

INTERACTIVE
AFFIRMED ALYDAR CAUTHEN VALASQUEZ
Timeline: The Kentucky Derby
The defining moments in more than a century of the Run for the Roses.
Slideshow
Image: Allison Baver
  Derby celebs
Plenty of stars from the entertainment and sports world attend the 136th Kentucky Derby.

more photos

INTERACTIVE
SECRETARIAT TURCOTTE
Triple Crown winners
The horses that have won the Kentucky Derby, Preakness and Belmont in the same year.