Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Mickelson a marvel at Pebble Beach, while Tiger tumbles

Next season's freshmen won't measure up

Instant impact players like Oden, Rose aren't part of 2008 recruiting class

Greg Monroe, Samardo SamuelsAP file
Greg Monroe dunks on a fast break in front Samardo Samuels during the Nike Hoop Summit in April. Both Monroe and Samuels are expected to be star freshmen next season for Georgetown and Louisville, respecitvely.

Mike DeCourcy
We've only been through this twice, but it did not take long to establish the pattern: The freshmen arrive, dominate the game and leave as suddenly as they appear. This new paradigm provided the thrill of watching Greg Oden block shots, Kevin Durant fling jumpers, Michael Beasley snatch rebounds and Derrick Rose hang in the air while inventing another impossible finish.

We shouldn't get too accustomed to this.

Next season's freshmen might believe they are ready to fill those shoes, whether it's the sneakers those fellows wore on court or the Ferragamos that carry them across the stage on NBA draft night. The recruiting class of 2008, however, does not feature that level of talent--which means somebody in this relationship is bound to be disappointed.

Either the freshmen are going to be hacked off that their dance into the NBA does not resemble the festive conga line their immediate predecessors enjoyed or the colleges are going to be steamed after a bunch of 11-pointsa- game guys pull a hit-and-run.

In the two years the NBA's age minimum has been in place, all but one player Scout.com ranked as a top five prospect -- North Carolina's Ty Lawson -- turned pro after a single season. That would translate into such players as Samardo Samuels and Jrue Holiday entering the draft next April -- and they're just not one-and-done talents.

Scout.com analyst Dave Telep thinks Samuels is likely to emerge as an instant college star. But Samuels is a 6-8, 240-pound low-post specialist with moderate athleticism, and the demand for such players in the NBA is not overwhelming.

There isn't a program in the country that wouldn't love to add Holiday, a 6-3 guard headed to UCLA. For Holiday to develop his package of athleticism, selflessness and burgeoning skill into an NBA-ready package will require a minimum of two years, possibly three if he is to grow into what should be his best pro position: point guard.

"These are multiyear people," Telep says. "You pick up your media guide and see, 'This school signed the No. 4 player in America.' Automatically, you're expecting what you've seen the past two years. You have to take off your school-colored glasses and look at the big picture."

Programs that wind up in the NCAA Tournament or advance to its later stages because of contributions from one-and-done players can justify the long-term disruption the departures cause. Players who turn into lottery picks after one season can view the NBA-forced delay of their paydays with some degree of tolerance.

But when neither side gets what it wants, these shotgun weddings may lead to some uneasy marriages.

© 2012 Sporting News

advertisement
More news
Image: Keith Appling, Branden Dawson, Brandon Wood
AP
Spartans take big step forward

Arc's five up, five down: After No. 11 Michigan State's 58-48 upset of No. 3 Ohio State, you'd be a fool to discount the Spartans' national title chances now.

Jordan Morgan, Meyers Leonard
AP
No. 22 Michigan beats Illinois

Tim Hardaway Jr. scored 15 points and Evan Smotrycz added 13, helping No. 22 Michigan remain unbeaten at home with a 70-61 win over Illinois on Sunday.

Slideshow
Florida v Kentucky
  College hoops power rankings
A look at the top teams in college basketball based on performance and potential.

NBCSports.com

College basketball videos
San Diego State v UNLV
Getty Images
Highlights: No. 14 UNLV 65, No. 13 SDSU 63
Mike Moser scored 19 points, and UNLV forced three turnovers in the final 42 seconds to win.

Slideshow
Western Kentucky v Louisville
  Three cheers for college hoops
Take a look at cheerleaders in action from around the country.

NBCSports.com

  Mike Miller's college hoops blog