Skip navigation

Small wonder Colts, Pats excel in NFL draft

Smart teams thrive thanks to solid player choices, development

Image: Polian
Stephen Dunn / Getty Images
Colts president Bill Polian has drafted 38 starters in 79 picks during his time in Indianapolis.
Special feature
Glenn Dorsey
Guaranteed top picks
The best players available in the 2008 NFL draft

NBCSports.com

Video
Arizona Cardinals v Chicago Bears
  Is Kurt Warner like Johnny U?
Peter King's notebook: A report on the future of the Cardinals quarterback, the Browns' general manager search and Cedric Benson's performance.

NBC Sports

Video: Football from NBC Sports
Arizona Cardinals v New York Giants
Getty Images
Fantasy Fix: Week 10 moves
Nov. 10: With four weeks remaining in the regular season, Gregg Rosenthal and Tiffany Simons break down the best moves for the stretch run, highlighting Anquan Boldin as a potential pickup.

Special feature
Green Bay Packers v Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Vote for supremacy
Who gets your vote: Will the pom-poms win another one or get crushed by the coozy?
Slideshow
Image: Green Bay Packers v Tampa Bay Buccaneers
  Sideline support
Check out some of the NFL cheerleaders from across the league.

more photos

Special feature
Ryan Leaf
Biggest draft busts
Check out the major mistakes NFL teams have made in the draft.

NBCSports.com

ASK THE NFL EXPERT
By Dan Pompei
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 11:03 p.m. ET April 23, 2008

Dan Pompei
They say drafting is an inexact science, but it is more inexact for some than others.

For instance, when was the last time Colts president Bill Polian blew a first round pick? Every one of his first rounders with the Colts has at the very least become a solid starter. You'd have to go back to 1996 when Polian took Tim Biakabutuka with the Panthers to find a Polian first rounder who could be called a bust. And Biakabutuka probably would have become a good player if he had been healthy.

Polian is the king of the draft. Of the 79 draft picks Polian has used since he has been in Indianapolis, 38 of them have become starters, and 11.3 percent of those players have become Pro Bowlers.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Polian's secret? Well, if you look at his history you'll see some trends. He likes big producers from big schools (hello, Peyton Manning). He isn't scared off of prospects who are considered too short or too light (see Freeney, Dwight, and Sanders, Bob). And he has a deep understanding of the types of players who fit in the Colts offensive and defensive systems (how many teams would have cut Robert Mathis?).

Marrying the player to the system is an underrated aspect of drafting. Some teams never get that. They think they can take any great college player and plug him into their system, and expect it to work.

The Patriots, with Bill Belichick and Scott Pioli working in tandem, fit the player to the system as well as anyone. Think about some of their draft choices who are square pegs in square holes: Vince Wilfork, Richard Seymour, Logan Mankins, Ben Watson. They have chosen seven Pro Bowlers in eight years.

Some drafters don't have the benefit of stable systems. They might draft a player for one system, only to find a coaching move has changed the system the following year.

The Cardinals fit into this category. Yet Rod Graves has been one of the most remarkable drafters in recent years. Graves has been in charge of the Cardinals draft for five years, and 18 of his 33 picks became NFL starters. During that period, he worked with Dave McGinnis, Dennis Green and Ken Whisenhunt.

Also among the best drafters in recent years have been the Ravens and Chargers. Ravens general manager Ozzie Newsome is in the Hall of Fame as a tight end, but he could make it as a drafter too.

Newsome has surrounded himself with great evaluators — Shack Harris and Phil Savage, who went on to run their own teams, and Eric DeCosta, who will be running his own team soon. But through a dozen drafts, Newsome has been the constant.

No current general manager has picked a higher percentage of Pro Bowl players than A.J. Smith of the Chargers. Twelve percent of his picks have gone to Honolulu. The Pro Bowlers: Philip Rivers, Nate Kaeding, Shawn Merriman, Antonio Cromartie and Marcus McNeill.

Video: What teams should do
So what do the Rams do?
Experts' mock draft, picks 1-8: Now that the Dolphins have inked Jake Long, where will Chris Long, Darren McFadden, Matt Ryan and Glenn Dorsey wind up?

Some of the teams that have struggled in the draft have done so in part because they have not sufficiently valued intangibles. The Bengals and Broncos, for instance, have taken some risks on players with character issues and subsequently regretted it.

Other teams aren't set up for player development.

The Redskins are more inclined to sign a free agent than to force a young player into the lineup. The result is they have drafted only nine starters over six years.

The Bucs under Jon Gruden are a veteran-oriented team. Only 27 percent of the team's draft picks over the last five years have become starters. It took Barrett Ruud three seasons to become the team's starting middle linebacker — but the second round pick from 2005 played well enough last year to make you wonder if he shouldn't have been starting as a rookie.

Drafting the right players is only part of the picture. Developing them is the other part.


Sponsored links