Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Riots spread as Greek lawmakers OK debt bill

No debating it: Kobe deserves MVP award

No matter how you look at it, Garnett, LeBron, Paul don't measure up

Image: Kobe BryantGetty Images
There is nothing to argue, Kobe Bryant is clearly the NBA's MVP this season, writes columnist Sam Smith.

Sam Smith
There's been this debate going on, like it does just about every year, about the league's Most Valuable Player.

I'm not sure why since it should be — and will be — without a doubt the Lakers' Kobe Bryant.

It is a bit annoying that so many people have this wrong, the general definition of wrong being if you disagree with me. But in this case, it's not only time for Bryant to receive his first ever MVP. It is wholly justified.

There are usually two ways of looking at this: Giving the reasons why your candidate deserves the award or the reasons why the other top contenders do not. In the fictional presidential spirit of at least appearing to avoid negative campaigning, we'll start with the reasons Bryant deserves the award and quickly seek the low road of eliminating the other contenders.

It's not lifetime achievement, though the player generally regarded by his peers as the best in the game for the last several years has yet to have an MVP award. There are good reasons Bryant should win, though. When Bryant was winning championships, it was with Shaquille O'Neal, who generally didn't win the award because he'd spend half the season getting into shape. Though since O'Neal was the dominant figure on the Lakers, it seemed inconceivable to give Bryant the award ahead of him.

After the Lakers' breakup in 2003, Bryant verged on the unpopular with some players, though more so with media members who vote. The pair essentially pushed media members to pick sides. If you were for Shaq, you were anti-Kobe. And O'Neal was far more popular. Plus, Bryant's Lakers struggled just to make the playoffs. And while there is no specific criterion for the voters, the MVP generally comes from the best team or close to it and certainly a 50-game winner. No MVP has come from a team winning fewer than 50 since Moses Malone's Rockets in 1982.

In recent years, Bryant has had brilliant individual seasons. But his team hasn't been among the elite. It's at least one reason why LeBron James, having a terrific individual season, has no chance to win the award, and shouldn't.

It also shouldn't matter that much that the Lakers made a late move into the top spot in the Western Conference. That's what seemed to fuel this ridiculous notion for a time that the Hornets' Chris Paul should be the MVP. Just because his team was a game or two better than Bryant's. How silly. Granted, Paul has been terrific. But it seems the sentiment toward him was more the surprise at the Hornets' ability to stay atop the Western Conference into April when many had not even picked them to make the playoffs. That miscalculation of predictions seems to drive a lot of postseason award voting. It's the notion that someone must have succeeded beyond expectations because the voter didn't see it coming. Could it be the voter misjudged the team or individual? Nah, not media voters.

No disrespect to Paul, but he's been just somewhat better than the Jazz's Deron Williams. Paul is an MVP candidate, particularly because he's been better defensively than Williams. But Paul's Hornets were downgraded because of the effects many felt the continued relocations would have as well as whether they could return from the injuries of last season.

Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

The Hornets have been healthy this season and have an All-Star in David West and a top rebounder in Tyson Chandler.

It's also one way of evaluating players in this voting: Who had the best supporting cast? Of course, there's also the Did-You-Make-Teammates Better test.

Kevin Garnett, who looks to me the only other legitimate contender, plays with perennial All-Stars in Paul Pierce and Ray Allen.

Garnett has been exceptional in revitalizing the Celtics in attitude, leadership and defense, though Garnett is not having one of his better statistical seasons. He isn't in the top 10 in any of the major statistical categories, though his presence with the league's most successful team is unmistakable. The Celtics have the best record and are the league's top defensive team because of Garnett and what he demands of his teammates.

Though compared with all the other top contenders, Bryant has had a remarkable season and to me raises questions whether there should even be any debate.


advertisement
More news
Image: Boston Celtics Rajon Rondo drives past Chicago Bulls Carlos Boozer in the second half of their NBA basketball game at TD Garden in Boston
Reuters
Rondo makes the Celtics go

  PBT: Boston's Rajon Rondo continues to be named in trade talks, which is madness. The Celtics guard creates offense and makes everyone around him better, which was evident in Sunday's win over the Bulls.

Rondo's triple-double carries Celtics over Bulls

Paul Pierce has been around long enough to know what Rajon Rondo's performance can mean for the aging Boston Celtics.

  ProBasketballTalk tweets

  1. Loading the latest posts…

Source: Twitter. For more, follow @basketballtalk.

Video: NBA from NBC Sports
Knicks, Lin still streaking
Knicks coach Mike D'Antoni and point guard Jeremy Lin discuss the team and Lin's recent success.

Slideshow
Washington Wizards v Charlotte Bobcats
  Get your cheer on
Check out some of the dancers from the NBA.

more photos

  Ask the NBA expert: Ira Winderman

Do you have a burning NBA question? Submit it now, and then check back for our reader mailbag.

Special feature
Image: LeBron James
Who will be MVP?
Interactive: Rank each player on a scale of 0 to 10 (10 = best player, 0 = barely worthy of consideration).

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Blake Griffin
  NBA All-Star starters
A look at the starting lineups for the East and West teams.

more photos