Skip navigation

Eli vs. Favre will only be a backstory

Defense and ground games — not QBs — will decide NFC title game

Grant sheds Jennings
Charlie Neibergall / AP
Running back Ryan Grant (25) runs past Seahawks cornerback Kelly Jennings during the first half of the Packers' 42-20 rout Saturday.
Video
  Favre, Packers plow ahead
Jan. 12: Brett Favre and Packers coach Mike McCarthy look ahead after beating the Seahawks.

NBC Sports

ProFootballTalk’s Picks
Philadelphia Eagles v Oakland Raiders
Key division showdowns looming
Eagles, Saints, Colts, Ravens, Patriots all headed for big victories against rivals

ProFootballTalk.com

Video: Football from NBC Sports
NFC East is overrated?
Nov. 7: Peter King and Mike Florio talk about the hot NFL topics including the lowly Browns, the Cowboys-Eagles matchup, the first half MVP and more.

Special feature
Houston Texans v Tennessee Titans
Vote for supremacy
Who gets your vote: Will the pom-poms start a streak or get flattened by the seat cushions?
Slideshow
Atlanta Falcons v New Orleans Saints
  Sideline support
Check out some of the NFL cheerleaders from across the league.

more photos

OPINION
By Mike Celizic
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 11:27 p.m. ET Jan. 13, 2008

Mike Celizic
All we’re going to hear about all week is Brett Favre and Eli Manning, Eli Manning and Brett Favre. It’s a good story line — the grizzled veteran and everybody’s hero and the kid brother of Peyton Manning trying to prove he is worthy of his own last name.

But unless one of them suffers a total meltdown, the quarterbacks aren’t going to be the difference in the NFC Championship Game. Like the divisional games the Packers and the Giants won this weekend, it’s going to be defense and the ground games that will carry the day.

Sure, the quarterback play will be important. But both teams will try to control the ball on the ground and let the air attack work off the rushing game, especially if we’re lucky enough to get another snowstorm.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Favre, the supposed gunslinger, threw just 23 times against Seattle, and he was marvelously efficient with those throws, completing 18 of them for 173 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions; he was sacked just once for zero yards lost. If it weren’t for that Brady guy in New England, it would have been the quarterbacking performance of the weekend.

Manning was even more parsimonious with his passing in the Giants’ upset of Dallas. He threw just 18 times, completing 12 of them for 163 yards, two touchdowns and no interceptions; he was sacked three times for -23 yards.

Green Bay, especially, relied on the run, with Ryan Grant overcoming two early fumbles and finishing with 201 yards on the snow-covered tundra. The Packers were going to win this game no matter what, but Grant’s running made it almost ridiculously easy.

Slide show
Image:
  Week in Sports Pictures
A Duck goes for a ride, a NASCAR driver takes flight, some bankers take to boxing, and much more.

more photos

New York didn’t run nearly as well, but did accumulate 90 yards against the Cowboys. Together with a terrific second-half defensive effort, they kept the pressure off Manning, who’s finest moments came with less than a minute left in the first half, when he led the Giants to the touchdown that tied the score at 14 and set up New York’s second-half heroics.

The Giants, especially, can’t allow the story line that unfolds in Green Bay to match the one your local newspapers and sports shows are going to be pushing. Manning has played far beyond what was expected of him against first Tampa and then Dallas. And one of the keys to his play has been the fact that he’s played both games on the road in mild weather.

In Green Bay, the weather can be a lot of things in mid-January, but one of them isn’t likely to be balmy. Manning has admitted he takes no pleasure in playing in the wind and rain and sleet of the Meadowlands. And the last thing you want to hear any athlete say is that he doesn’t perform well in certain conditions. Once that’s in his head, it’s hard to get out.

So, if the game falls on Manning’s shoulders, it’s going to mean that the Giants are losing and all else has failed. And if it’s come to that, New York probably isn’t going to win.


Sponsored links