Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Adele is Grammys big winner, Whitney honored

Tebow didn't deserve to win Heisman

In fact, Florida star wasn't even among top three picks on my ballot

Heisman Trophy FootballAP
Arkansas tailback Darren McFadden rushed for 206 yards and three touchdowns and passed for another TD against then-No. 1 LSU and that performance should have lifted him to the Heisman Trophy, writes msnbc.com contributor Ken Davis.

Ken Davis
This won’t settle well in Gainesville, Fla. I’ve never been there. And it’s not likely I’ll be invited to visit any time soon.

Not after this column.

Florida quarterback Tim Tebow didn’t deserve the Heisman Trophy. Not this year. In fact, he didn’t even make the top three picks on my ballot. Let that sink in for a minute and then we can move on to my reasons.

It’s not because Tebow is a sophomore. Even though Tebow was the first sophomore to win the trophy, the Heisman isn’t about class status. Any one who votes that way is narrow minded and wrong. The award is not designated to go to the most outstanding senior.

And this isn’t personal. I have nothing against Tebow or Florida. I’m told he’s a fine young man, but this isn’t a popularity contest. One quick disclaimer: I do have relatives living in Tallahassee, Fla. My sister-in-law and my nephew graduated from Florida State and are avid Seminoles fans. But they did not influence my thinking in any way. They did not bribe me or pay me (although there are plenty of shopping days remaining before Christmas and I love to be rewarded).

But, let’s get serious.

It’s easy to understand the support Tebow received. The statistics are there to back him. The 6-foot-3, 235-pound quarterback for the Gators is the first player in NCAA history to run for at least 20 touchdowns and pass for at least 20 touchdowns in the same season. He passed for 29 and rushed for 22. He broke Florida’s single-season record for total offense with 3,970 yards and broke the Southeastern Conference’s single-season record for rushing touchdowns.

Tebow has taken full advantage of coach Urban Meyer’s offense. He ranks second in the nation in passing efficiency (177.9), completing 68.5 percent of his passes with only six interceptions.

All of that deserves tremendous respect. And the fact Tebow toiled under such scrutiny demands admiration. The quarterback at Florida works under unique pressure. He entered the season with questions about his ability to throw the ball and he certainly quieted the critics.

A quarterback’s job is to get his team into the end zone. Tebow did that better than anybody, but the No. 1 duty on a quarterback’s job description is to lead his team to victory. That may sound harsh, but it is a reality. Great teams have great quarterbacks. And there is more to greatness than just piling up statistics.

Florida was 9-3 overall and 5-3 in the SEC. Teams with three losses don’t enter the BCS discussion. Florida didn’t win the SEC East. The Gators didn’t play in the SEC championship game. LSU beat Tennessee for the conference championship and advanced to the national championship game with two losses. Georgia has been widely discussed as one of the hottest teams in the nation.

Florida? The Gators lost to Auburn, LSU and Georgia and are headed to the Capital One Bowl to play Michigan. Tebow did not lift the Gators to great heights. After the loss to Georgia, he padded his stats with wins over Vanderbilt, South Carolina, Florida Atlantic and Florida State.

If you want to talk about quarterbacks who carried their teams to great heights this season, the list includes Dennis Dixon of Oregon, Pat White of West Virginia, Colt Brennan of Hawaii, Chase Daniel of Missouri and Todd Reesing of Kansas. With both Dixon and White, their importance to their teams became crystal clear when they were injured. Brennan led Hawaii to a perfect season and a berth in the Sugar Bowl. His outrageous numbers are the result of an offensive system as well, but look at the way he rallied his team from behind and lifted a program from a non-BCS conference into a BCS bowl.


advertisement
More news
Image: Boston College v Miami
Getty Images
'I'm taking that program down'

Miami coach Al Golden says the worst is behind him, but his headaches figure to continue now that former booster Nevin Shapiro, now in jail, says his involvement with the Hurricanes program will result in stiff penalties.

Image: LSU quarterback Jefferson is stripped of the ball by Alabama's Hightower during the second half of the NCAA BCS National Championship college football game in New Orleans
Reuters
CFT: Jefferson says 'Alabama was more prepared'

CFT: Jordan Jefferson makes it clear he wasn't happy with LSU's game plan in the Tigers' BCS Championship Game loss to Alabama.

Video: Football from NBC Sports
Memphis fulfills BCS dream
Tigers officials thrilled to announce that school has been accepted to join the Big East Conference in 2013.

Slideshow
Image: Joe Paterno
  Joe Paterno (1926-2012)
A look at the career of legendary Penn State coach Joe Paterno

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image:
  BCS title game
Check out photos of Crimson Tide's victory over Tigers.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Kansas State running back Pease is tackled by Arkansas defensive tackle Jones during the Cotton Bowl Classic football game in Arlington, Texas
  Bowled over
Check out the action from the postseason games.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Kansas vs Oklahoma State
  All-American team
Check out which players were best of the best at each position.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Rose Bowl Game presented by Vizio - Wisconsin v Oregon
  College cheer
Check out some of the college football cheerleaders from across the country.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos