Skip navigation

Ohio State better not let us all down again

If Buckeyes flop again in title game, declining Big Ten should pay a price

Image: Clarett
Ted S. Warren / AP file
The last time the Big Ten had a worthy contender in the national title game, Maurice Clarett helped the Buckeyes to 31-24 win against Miami in the 2003 Fiesta Bowl, writes Mike Celizic.
Slide show
Image:  LSU defensive standout Glenn Dorsey
  Players to watch
Buckeyes, Tigers who probably will play key roles in the BCS championship game.

more photos

Video: Football from NBC Sports
Stanford ready for Notre Dame
Nov. 25: Stanford head coach Jim Harbaugh previews what his team needs to do to beat the Irish for the first time since 2001.

Special feature
Kansas v Texas
Predictions 101
Texas will hand Texas A&M a rare road loss, while Cincinnati will overpower Illinois.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
LSU v Alabama
  College cheer
Check out some of the college football cheerleaders from across the country.
Slide show
Image: Ding Jianjun
  Week in Sports Pictures
Pain on the skating rink, flying high on the hardwood, upsets on the football field, and more.

more photos

OPINION
By Mike Celizic
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 1:45 p.m. ET Dec. 3, 2007

Mike Celizic
There’s nothing to be done for it now. Ohio State is in the BCS Championship Game, and it’s too late to ask for a recount of the votes and a reboot of the silly computers that somehow chose the Buckeyes as a championship-caliber team.

But this should be it for the Buckeyes and the Big Ten. Either beat LSU, a two-loss SEC team, or we pass a new rule for the BCS that would go something like this: Two losses in the SEC or Big 12 are equal to zero losses in the Big Ten. So unless a Big Ten team is undefeated and nobody else is around to play for the title, the Big Ten doesn’t get in.

Ohio State and Big Ten fans may find this harsh and uncaring, and it is. But it’s also based on fact. It’s time to admit it: In big situations, the conference is more like the Little Ten.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Ohio State is 0-8 in bowl games against the SEC and just 18-20 in bowl games since going to its first one in 1921. That record includes a 4-1 run in the Buckeyes’ first five bowls. Since then, they’re 14-19. This isn’t the stuff of legends.

The Big Ten dominates headlines but not college football. Its teams rarely go very far abroad to find top-notch out-of-conference foes, usually resorting to Notre Dame. Ohio State did take on Texas in a home-and-home in 2005-06, losing the first and winning the second, And next year, it’s playing USC in the first of a two-year series.

That’s progress, and maybe the BCS rule ought to be that a Big Ten team has to beat a quality opponent out of conference before it can play in the title game. That at least legitimizes the Buckeyes’ presence in the title game last year. But this year, they beat no one out of conference (Youngstown State, Akron, Washington and Kent State) and lost to Illinois in the Big Ten. I don’t think that’s good enough.

The Buckeyes can change my mind by not just showing up against LSU, but beating them. I know LSU has two losses, but I don’t think the Buckeyes will end the night looking as if they belong on the same field. They seldom do.

It’s not the Buckeyes’ fault, I suppose, that they end up with these high rankings. It’s the conference itself. Just look at the Big Ten’s record in the national championship picture.

Yes, Michigan won in 1997 (which it shared with Nebraska) and the Buckeyes won for the 2002 season, but before that you have to go back to 1968 to find another Big Ten champion, when Ohio State won the polls that decided things in those days. So the entire celebrated conference has three titles in 40 seasons. That’s hardly the sign of greatness; a number of schools have that many or more titles in that period all by themselves.

It’s been popular to rip on the Big East as the weakest conference in the BCS, but that’s just wrong. The Big Ten is no stronger. Neither, for that matter, is the Pac-10, which has one superior team — USC — and that’s it.

The power lives in the SEC and Big 12. Oklahoma would probably give LSU a better game. I’m not sure Georgia would; I’m also not sure it wouldn’t.


Sponsored links