updated 11:31 p.m. ET Dec. 1, 2007

MORGANTOWN, W.Va. - Rich Rodriguez could barely get the words out. He paused. He shook his head. He looked down at the table in front of him, as if searching for a way to describe how West Virginia let its chance at a national title slip away.

Eventually the Mountaineers' coach came up with this.

"It was just a nightmare," he said. "The whole thing was a nightmare."

In a season defined by upsets, the second-ranked Mountaineers became the latest to be felled by the curse of No. 2, falling to their fierce rival Pittsburgh 13-9 Saturday night.

A win away from playing for the national championship, the Mountaineers (10-2, 5-2 Big East) were expected to roll over rival Pittsburgh (5-7, 3-4) in the 100th Brackyard Brawl on their way to New Orleans for the Bowl Championship Series title game.

No way. Not in this unpredictable season, when nothing has gone according to plan and upsets have become so frequent the word itself has almost lost its meaning.

Pitt, which had lost four of the last five to West Virginia and allowed 45 points to the Mountaineers in each of the last two games in the series, celebrated the biggest victory of coach Dave Wannstedt's three lackluster seasons.

"I remember walking off the field two years ago at halftime saying that we needed to run faster," said Wannstedt, who received a three-year contract extension on Friday. "Today, we ran faster."

The Pitt coach improved to 16-19 and repaid the university for its show of faith with a BCS-busting victory

"It's exciting to know people believe in you, even after a difficult season," said Wannstedt, who like Rodriguez is coaching his alma mater.

No. 2 had already lost six times this season, five times to unranked teams. In a year when Appalachian State beat Michigan and 41-point underdog Stanford beat Southern California, West Virginia losing as a four-touchdown favorite probably shouldn't even be all that shocking.

Especially after the Mountaineers lost Heisman Trophy contender Pat White to a dislocated thumb in the second quarter. White tried to play in the fourth quarter, but he couldn't put together a comeback.

"I just wanted to help the team as much as I can," White said. "It was killing me sitting on the sidelines."

When Pitt punter Dave Brytus ran out of the end zone for a safety on the final clock-killing play, West Virginia, a program that has won more games then any other in major college football without winning a national title, was done.

WVU Fans sat stone faced. The Panthers did some dancing on the WV logo at midfield. Some West Virginia players took offense and there was a push or two. Most of the Mountaineers just trudged off slowly.

"If we would have lost every game this season and won this game, my season is a success," Pitt offensive lineman Mike McGlynn said. "They were going to try to get their team into the national championship. They tried. It didn't happen."

Sitting at home in Columbus, Ohio, the Buckeyes got the last upset they needed to get themselves back in the national title game.

In fact, they got it twice. No. 1 Missouri lost in the Big 12 championship game 38-17 to No. 9 Oklahoma, making the BCS a total mess heading into selection Sunday.

Almost a month ago, Ohio State was No. 1 and in control of the Bowl Championship Series title race when it lost at home 28-21 to Illinois. The Buckeyes beat Michigan a week later to lock up the Big Ten then watched week after week as the other contenders went down.

They needed one more to fall Saturday and West Virginia was first to oblige.

Today the Mountaineers will have to be content with their second BCS bid in the last three seasons and a trip to the Orange or Sugar bowls.

"We picked a bad time to play our worst game offensively in years," Rodriguez said.

Don't miss this on MSNBC.com Pass it on: Sons of infertile men may be next The eight biggest Olympic marketing debacles Reality show judges range from wise to wacko Cosmic Log: Is this your jetpack? Forget your inhibitions: World's sexiest islands

The Mountaineers' struggled offensively even before White went out. They squandered two scoring opportunities in the first quarter, missing short field goals, and finished with a season-low 183 yards and only nine first downs. That's usually a good quarter for West Virginia, which came in averaging 310 yards rushing and 42 points.

"It was just frustrating we weren't able to put the ball in the end zone," said White, who had run for over 100 yards in each of his last four games. "It hurts, but everything happens for a reason."

MORE FROM COLLEGE FOOTBALL

College football Section Front

SEC not all it’s cracked up to be Bowl Projections: Big Ten blows BCS spot Opinion: 10 bowl matchups that would be a treat CFT: ‘By the numbers’ — McCoy goes for record CFT: Iowa’s Stanzi could return for bowl game CFT: Meyer says Florida ‘lacking the big hits’ Tribe stops school from dropping nickname   Vote: Which is the best conference? CFT: Mystery over for No. 5 Cincinnati — Pike will sit Iowa-Ohio St. in-depth video preview, analysis College football Section Front   Add College football headlines to your news reader: