Skip navigation

Fall for Panthers leaves Fox's future uncertain

Awful QB play, mental errors, signs the players have quit may doom coach

Video
  King's Notebook: Week 11
Nov. 22: Dan Patrick and Peter King break down the wild finish in Detroit, highlighting the clutch play of Matthew Stafford and the decision making of Eric Mangini.

NBC Sports

Slideshow
Denver Broncos v Washington Redskins
  Sideline support
Check out some of the NFL cheerleaders from across the league.

more photos

OPINION
By Mike Cranston
Associated Press Sports
updated 4:00 p.m. ET Nov. 27, 2007

CHARLOTTE, N.C. - John Fox inherited a 1-15 team in Carolina and had the Panthers in the Super Bowl two years later.

After reaching the NFC championship game two years after that, the Panthers entered the 2006 season as the trendy pick to make the Super Bowl.

Boy, does that seem like a long time ago.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Sunday's horrific 31-6 home loss to New Orleans was eerily similar to the end of the George Seifert era in 2001. There was awful quarterback play, mental errors and signs the Panthers have stopped playing for their coach.

Things happen quickly in the NFL, and Fox and general manager Marty Hurney have gone from highly regarded to among those with uncertain futures after a series of bad personnel moves and uninspired play.

"The buck stops here,'' Fox said after Sunday's loss, the Panthers' fifth consecutive overall and seventh straight at home dating to last season.

A day later, Fox was asked to evaluate his performance.

"That's for other people,'' said Fox, whose contract runs through 2010. "We're not pleased with where we are right now. We still have five games to go and those decisions are not in my control.''

The man making those decisions, owner Jerry Richardson, isn't talking. The former NFL receiver, who played with Johnny Unitas in Baltimore, rarely speaks in public. A team spokesman said Tuesday it's Richardson's practice not to comment until after the season.

But Richardson hasn't kept a coach if Carolina has finished with less than seven wins.

Dom Capers was fired in 1998 after going 4-12, only two years removed from leading the Panthers to the NFC title game in their second year of existence.

Seifert was a goner after 2001, two years after nearly squeaking into the playoffs in his first year.

Realistically, the Panthers (4-7) have only one winnable game left, Sunday against San Francisco (3-8). Their final four games are against Jacksonville (8-3), Seattle (7-4), Dallas (10-1) and Tampa Bay (7-4).

And with the way they looked Sunday against the Saints - their sixth loss by 13 or more points - it's hard to envision the Panthers beating anyone.

The argument for keeping Fox and Hurney is that the season was ruined when Jake Delhomme was lost to a season-ending elbow injury.

But a look around the league Sunday saw backup quarterbacks Daunte Culpepper and Trent Dilfer leading their teams to wins. Philadelphia's A.J. Feeley, in his first start since 2004, nearly helped the Eagles to an upset of New England.

And the Panthers' miserable performance came with one of the top quarterbacks available in the offseason, David Carr.

After going 8-8 last season, Fox and Hurney made few moves, pinning the poor year on injuries. But they did want to upgrade at quarterback. They released Chris Weinke, the starter in Seifert's 1-15 season, and gave Carr a two-year, $6 million deal.

Slide show
Image: Ding Jianjun
  Week in Sports Pictures
Pain on the skating rink, flying high on the hardwood, upsets on the football field, and more.

more photos

Perhaps the first signal it was a bad move was at his introductory news conference. Carr said he was more than happy to go from a five-year starter in Houston to a backup, saying he needed to "take a deep breath'' after being sacked 249 times with the Texans.

Carr's time off ended when Delhomme went down in Week 3, and he's been shockingly bad. Carr has lacked accuracy, can't find receivers downfield and holds onto the ball too long. He's lacked fire, and the team hasn't responded to him.

Fox planned to start 44-year-old Vinny Testaverde against the Saints, until Testaverde's back locked up Saturday. Fox said Testaverde will start Sunday against the 49ers, if he's healthy. What does that say about Carr?

Maybe Carr's woes shouldn't have been a surprise. The long-held view in Houston was that Carr wasn't the victim of a bad offensive line as much as his own inept play.

After Carr was released, Texans receiver Andre Johnson said Carr had to learn to go through reads under new coach Gary Kubiak after being told where to throw the ball on every down with their old coach.

That coach, coincidentally, was Capers.

"It was like he was starting all over again,'' Johnson said.

The failed decision to sign Carr - it's unimaginable he'll be back next season - is another in a long list of moves that have backfired.


Sponsored links