Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Biden praises West Point's '9/11 generation'

Change in goalies made little difference

Coach guilty of bonehead move, but Brazil far superior to U.S. women

Ryan, BoxxAFP/Getty Images
U.S. coach Greg Ryan talks to Shannon Boxx after she was ejected from a 4-0 loss to Brazil in the semifinals of the Women's World Cup on Thursday.

JIM LITKE
Jim Litke
AP columnist
Don’t get distracted by the blame game. Brazil was every bit as good as the 4-0 beating it administered to the United States in the Women’s World Cup semifinal indicated — and maybe even better than that.

Although U.S. coach Greg Ryan’s decision to switch goalkeepers at the 11th hour was hardly his only knuckleheaded move during the tournament, that didn’t cost his team the game. It didn’t help, to be sure, and neither did the disruptive, destructive whining by Hope Solo, who lost her starting job to Briana Scurry.

Yet even if Ryan could have played them on the goal line side-by-side, it would have made little difference. That’s how thoroughly the day belonged to the Samba Queens, start to finish. They had nearly twice as much possession and more than twice as many shots on goal.

Ditto for the sending off of U.S. midfielder Shannon Boxx, which forced the U.S. team to play the second half with only 10 players. Granted, her second yellow card, in stoppage time at the end of the first half, was a horrible call by referee Nicole Petignat. But the Americans were overmatched and already down 2-0. If the equally overmatched Petignat hadn’t blown an equally outrageous call on a missed penalty when Brazil’s Cristiane was taken down in the box earlier, it would have been 3-0 by then.

It’s both a blessing and a curse for soccer in this country that most Americans pay attention only when the World Cup or Olympics roll around.

Even so, expectations for the women’s team were much greater than they ever have been for the men. Not just because they were the class of the field when international play began in earnest in 1991, but also because Mia Hamm, the game’s first real superstar, is an American and many of the most recognizable faces during that reign happened to be her teammates.

On top of that, opportunities and support for female athletes are still better here than anywhere else, even factoring in the failure of a women’s pro soccer league a few years back.

Still, just like the men, the women suffer from the lack of a real soccer culture here. The women don’t lose nearly as many topflight athletes to other sports, but like the men, nearly all of them begin playing soccer in organized leagues, taught by volunteers just learning the game themselves.

The coaching gets better as players advance through the national team ranks, but there’s no substitute for the imagination players develop playing countless pickup games in narrow alleyways or on tiny, dirt-encrusted fields, where the ability to improvise or anticipate a quirky bounce is everything.

If you want to see how that manifests itself at the highest levels, watch a video clip of Marta’s second goal in the 79th minute for Brazil. With apologies to Hamm, she’s already more skillful with the ball than Mia ever was. And the behind-the-back flick she used to beat U.S. defender Tina Ellertson on the left edge of the box showed her to be just as audacious as anybody on Brazil’s men’s team, for whom the term “o jogo bonito” — “the beautiful game” — was invented.

Slideshow
Image:
  The Week in Sports Pictures
A kayaker flips out, a racehorse eyes the Triple Crown and more.

more photos

For more than a decade, the U.S. women’s superior athleticism was enough of an advantage to win nearly every time out. But a number of the other top national teams closed that gap in recent years, and their women developed an understanding of how to play together that the U.S. team displays only occasionally. Most of the time, the Americans’ offensive strategy consisted of kicking the ball long and down the middle of the field, relying on striker Abby Wambach to retrieve it, then beat several defenders, usually single-handedly.

It’s fair to question whether Ryan was in over his head as well. His substitutions were suspect for much of the tournament. The last-minute goalkeeping switch smacked of desperation, and the unsettling effect it had on his team was evident in the 20th minute, when a miscommunication between Scurry and midfielder Leslie Osborne on a Brazil corner produced an own goal.

None of that, though justified Solo’s sniping before the game or her outlandish claim afterward.

“It was the wrong decision, and I think anybody that knows anything about the game knows that,” she said. “There’s no doubt in my mind I would have made those saves. And the fact of the matter is it’s not 2004 anymore. ... It’s 2007, and I think you have to live in the present. And you can’t live by big names. You can’t live in the past.”

Ryan may be guilty as charged. But he’s not the only one.

© 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

advertisement
More news
Image:
AP
'I want to play in Champions League'

PST: American star Clint Dempsey doesn't talk like a man who is going stay with Fulham.

Image: Los Angeles Galaxy v Montreal Impact
Getty Images
PST: Beckham gets away with stuff others don't

PST: Let’s talk about the elephant in the MLS room. It’s David Beckham’s treatment by the men in the middle. And possibly by the league, where the question of “double-standard” may be getting a big test.

Slideshow
2012 Vanity Fair Oscar Party Hosted By Graydon Carter - Arrivals
  Just for kicks: Soccer WAGs
Take a look at soccer wives and girlfriends from all over the world.