Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: 9 die in Kosovo avalanche; child survives

Is fighting giving hockey a black eye?

Orr's decking of Fedoruk, Simon's stick attack raise concerns for some

Orr KO's FedorukReuters
The New York Rangers' Colton Orr (28) stands over the Philadelphia Flyers' Todd Fedoruk after knocking him out on Wednesday.

Punches have been a part of hockey every bit as long as pucks.

With the NHL facing an ongoing image problem, the debate rages as to what role fighting plays. To the die-hards and purists, the act of dropping the gloves is not only popular, but a necessary part of policing the game. There is even a Web site dedicated to charting bouts.

To others in the mainstream sports scene, it is an antiquated act of foolishness — merely a sideshow that caters to the same group of people who watch auto racing with the hopes of seeing a fiery crash.

New York Rangers enforcer Colton Orr — yes, hockey is the one sport in which such a title is given — flattened Philadelphia counterpart Todd Fedoruk with a straight right hand during a fight 21 seconds into a 5-0 victory Wednesday night.

“It’s probably time that the general managers ask the question, 'Where are we at with this?”’ NHL disciplinarian Colin Campbell told The Associated Press. “I am not saying that it should be abolished, but I think we always should ask questions. Cultures change, times change, players change.

“If a player is going to get damaged to the point it’s going to affect him in a severe way, it’s incumbent upon us all to ask questions.”

Fighting is outlawed in the Olympics and quite rare in the playoffs. A bigger problem is Orr-Fedoruk came on the heels of other highly publicized acts of violence by Chris Simon and Jordin Tootoo that marred NHL games.

“There’s not a lot of fights comparatively if you look to 10 years or 20 years ago,” said Campbell, a former Rangers coach and frequent fighter during his playing career. “A lot of people have complained that fighting has its place in the game and that we don’t have enough of it. Things like the Simon thing and other things happen because they say they don’t have a release valve in any other sort of manner.”

Having players knocked out and hospitalized gives the league a black eye, but traditional fighting isn’t comparable to the vicious stick attack by New York Islanders forward Simon against Orr’s teammate Ryan Hollweg, or the gloved punch by Nashville’s Tootoo that decked Dallas defenseman Stephane Robidas as he came to defend Stars teammate Mike Modano.

“We play 1,500 games a year,” Campbell said. “Incidents like this happen, unfortunately. Not every season, but they happen. Because they’ve happened close together people tend to draw a quick conclusion.”

Simon’s act drew a suspension of at least 25 games. Tootoo’s intent and the injury he inflicted cost him five games, Campbell said.

“Guys are taking a little bit of liberties, whereas a couple years ago you had to be held accountable,” Atlanta’s Keith Tkachuk said. “You want to do something but you can’t because you’re worried about the consequences. Guys have to be more careful and have a little more respect for each other.”

Right or wrong, there is great pride in this line of work. Fighting carries a sense of importance and even has its own code of ethics to which the most powerful of brawlers adhere. Third-man in and bench-clearing scenes are long gone.

“It was just a fair fight,” said Orr, who has 27 bouts on his resume. “He is going to hit you so you want to hit him. The same thing could’ve happened to me. It is part of the game.”

Although it is sure to be lumped in with other rough acts, there really is no comparison. While fighting is allowed — carrying only a five-minute penalty — stick fouls, unprovoked attacks, and instigating is not.

“The image doesn’t bother me,” Campbell said of fighting. “There are images in all sports: cars crashing, boxers going down, baseball brawls. I think people in hockey are OK with it. It’s the injuries that scare you.”


advertisement
Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

Video: NHL from NBC Sports
Gretzky says Cup race is wide open
In the latest NHL Network news update, Hall of Famer Wayne Gretzky talks about the division races and how 22 teams have a shot to win it all this year.

Slideshow
Image: Chicago Blackhawks Marian Hossa of Team Chara celebrates his goal with New York Rangers Marion Gaborik during the NHL All-Star hockey game in Ottawa
  NHL All-Stars
Take a look at the players who competed in Team Chara's 12-9 victory over Team Alfredsson.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Stanley Cup Finals - Pittsburgh Penguins v Detroit Red Wings - Game Seven
  Sid the Kid
Penguins captain Sidney Crosby has gone from phenom to Stanley Cup champion.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Washington Capitals Ovechkin celebrates his goal against the Montreal Canadiens during Game 5 in Washington
  Alexander the Great
Take a look at Capitals star and two-time MVP Alexander Ovechkin

more photos

Slideshow
Pamela Anderson
  Celebrity fans
Some of Hollywood's hottest celebrities take in NHL games.
Slideshow
Colorado Avalanche v Anaheim Ducks
  Icy Hot
Check out the ice girls from around the National Hockey League.

more photos