Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Rioters burn 45 buildings as Greece backs cuts

Simon punishment not harsh enough

Islander got off easy with 25-game suspension for hit on Hollweg

SimonAP
Chris Simon got off easy. He should not have the option of playing in an NHL game until the 2008-09 season. And if that were to end his career, so be it, SN's Kara Yorio says.

Kara Yorio
Chris Simon got off easy. He should not have the option of playing in an NHL game until the 2008-09 season. And if that were to end his career, so be it.

Ignore that Ryan Hollweg somehow survived Simon's brutal stick attack with only some stitches in his chin. Never mind Simon's claims that he has a concussion from Hollweg's hit from behind and didn't know what he was doing when he hunted Hollweg and swung his stick at his head. Concussions are an injury of convenience in this league -- most often ignored at the player's peril and sometimes diagnosed and discussed when it could benefit the player or his team.

Simon is responsible for his actions. Others have played with concussions and not done what he did. And the lack of a serious injury to Hollweg doesn't lessen the offense, either.

If Hollweg were lying in a hospital right now in a coma, would the league's punishment have been more severe? There is no doubt in my mind.

That is a mistake. It is part of the problem with the sliding scales of justice in the NHL, the unwillingness to have a blanket punishment for hits to the head or assaults with the stick. It's nice to judge things on a case-by-case basis, in theory. In practicality, it just keeps the incidents coming.

But the league will defend itself and call this decision harsh. In numbers, Simon's minimum 25-game suspension will look bigger than the one Marty McSorley received more than seven years ago when he hit Donald Brashear in the head with his stick. But that's a technicality. McSorley's punishment was much more severe. He missed the final 23 games of the regular season, but commissioner Gary Bettman extended the suspension to a calendar year. McSorley was 36 years old at the time of the incident and never got back to the NHL.

Simon's suspension for his two-handed swing at Hollweg's head nets him this minimum 25-game suspension. It includes the Islanders' final 15 games of the regular season and any playoff games they may play. If they play fewer than 10 playoff games, the suspension would continue over into next season until he has missed 25 NHL games. The maximum the suspension could be is 43 games -- if the Islanders were to play four, seven-game series in the playoffs.

In the offseason, Simon will be free to sign with whoever is willing to take him. At 35, maybe he won't get another offer, but chances are he will. It's a good bet Chris Simon will be in an NHL game next October and for that, the league should be ashamed.

This is not about Chris Simon, the man. This is about Chris Simon's actions. Those actions say he shouldn't step on the ice as an NHL player the rest of this season and all of next season. The league's decision says he can. It's too bad.


© 2012 Sporting News

advertisement
More news
Image: Niklas Kronwall, Danny Briere
AP
Wings win 20th straight at home

  The Detroit Red Wings equaled an NHL record with their 20th straight win at home, beating the Philadelphia Flyers 4-3 Sunday night on the strength of Johan Franzen's tiebreaking goal early in the third period.

NBC Sports
Highlights: Flyers fall to Red Wings

    Detroit powers past Philadelphia with a 4-3 win

Slideshow
Image: Chicago Blackhawks Marian Hossa of Team Chara celebrates his goal with New York Rangers Marion Gaborik during the NHL All-Star hockey game in Ottawa
  NHL All-Stars
Take a look at the players who competed in Team Chara's 12-9 victory over Team Alfredsson.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Stanley Cup Finals - Pittsburgh Penguins v Detroit Red Wings - Game Seven
  Sid the Kid
Penguins captain Sidney Crosby has gone from phenom to Stanley Cup champion.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Washington Capitals Ovechkin celebrates his goal against the Montreal Canadiens during Game 5 in Washington
  Alexander the Great
Take a look at Capitals star and two-time MVP Alexander Ovechkin

more photos

Slideshow
Pamela Anderson
  Celebrity fans
Some of Hollywood's hottest celebrities take in NHL games.
Slideshow
Colorado Avalanche v Anaheim Ducks
  Icy Hot
Check out the ice girls from around the National Hockey League.

more photos

Slideshow
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos