Skip navigation

Squeeze play endangers Maryland racing

As Laurel and Pimlico flounder, tracks in nearby states flourish with slots

People play slot machines
Matt Rourke / AP file
People play slot machines at Philadelphia Park Casino in Bensalem, Pa., near Philadelphia, on Dec. 19.
  DAILY RACING FORM
Daily Racing FormDaily Racing Form
Slide show
Image: Ding Jianjun
  Week in Sports Pictures
Pain on the skating rink, flying high on the hardwood, upsets on the football field, and more.

more photos

Video
  Filly wins Preakness thriller
Rachel Alexandra holds off Derby winner Mine That Bird to become first female to win race since 1924.

NBC Sports

Video
  Preakness Overhead Cam
May 16: Watch Rachel Alexandra hold off Mine That Bird on the overhead cam.

NBC Sports

By Marty McGee
Daily Racing Form
updated 8:53 p.m. ET Feb. 26, 2007

LAUREL, Md. - Just a few feet inside the main entrance of Laurel Park on a recent weekday, a five-gallon bucket sat in the middle of the floor, catching a steady stream of droplets from a cracked roof several stories above.

Not that this much mattered, since there were precious few customers to actually see it. In stark contrast to bygone days, Laurel sits virtually empty even as horses race across its track, a testament to how progress and modernization have eluded it. Less than 20 years ago, Laurel and its fellow Maryland Jockey Club track, Pimlico, were perhaps second only to the New York Racing Association tracks along the Eastern seaboard.

Today, however, Laurel is struggling mightily, and the leaky-roof metaphor that Maryland fans once cast with condescension toward the Charles Town Races or Philadelphia Park has boomeranged with a cruel reality. Tracks in several states adjacent to Maryland are flourishing, buoyed by slots revenues that allow them to lure the horses and horsemen who otherwise might be racing in Maryland. While many people in racing are reluctant to call slots a panacea, there can be no doubt that West Virginia, Delaware, and now Pennsylvania -- states with racing programs that once were clearly inferior to what Maryland offered -- are more vibrant and successful than Maryland for reasons directly traceable to their onsite slot machines.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Not that nobody saw it coming. For years, proponents of Maryland racing have warned that they will be overwhelmed by neighboring competition if some form of alternative gaming is not legalized at state tracks. And as time has passed, and the competitive gulf has widened, the straits have become more desperate.

“We are in survival mode,” said Lou Raffetto Jr., the president and chief executive officer of the MJC, which is owned by Magna Entertainment. “It forces one to make moves one normally wouldn’t make.”

The most recent and overt manifestation of that desperation came Jan. 25, when the MJC, citing a financial inability to justify the $500,000 purse, announced it would not be able to run the Grade 1 Pimlico Special on May 18. The Pimlico Special has long been recognized as the second-best race on the circuit, behind only the Preakness, and its cancellation came as a jolting reminder of how far Maryland racing has fallen. Since being revived in 1988 following a 30-year hiatus, the Pimlico Special also was discontinued once before, in 2002, for essentially the same reasons as this year.

“Our horsemen don’t care that much about the Pimlico Special since it’s usually an out-of-town horse that wins it,” said Raffetto. “But they do understand the prestige it brings to our program. Still, knowing the shortfalls we face, we couldn’t sit back and cut our overnight races while using $500,000 for one race.”

Raffetto said the MJC has been using reserve funds totaling nearly $8 million to overpay purses during the 2006-07 racing seasons just to keep overnight purse levels at roughly $200,000 per day.

“Come 2008, without slots or some sort of subsidy, our landscape will change even more dramatically,” he said. “We cannot maintain that $200,000 level - at least not for anywhere close to the 184 days a year we’ve been running - because there simply is no more money. This is not some hollow threat.”

Counting stakes, the average per-day purse payout over 184 race dates in 2006 at Laurel and Pimlico was almost $240,000, compared with about $212,000 when 219 dates were run in 2001. Raffetto said these levels are unsatisfactory, especially when compared with the sharp purse increases that occurred in Delaware and West Virginia, and what is expected for Pennsylvania, when their tracks were remade into racinos.

The prospect of Maryland eventually getting slots at state racetracks hinges on a complex set of political factors, and debate about the need for slots is arguably the state’s hottest political potato. Ultimately, it could be the state’s own dire financial plight that will finally lead to the approval of slots by the state legislature: Maryland faces a $1.8 billion budgetary deficit in 2008.

Maryland racing and the state itself “are both like ships sinking,” said Raffetto. “We both know we have huge financial problems - and once you’re under water, it’s that much harder to get back to the surface. Right now is the time to start thinking about a solution. We know that, and most of the legislators know it, too.”

Raffetto said he strongly believes that a slots bill will be passed by the Maryland legislature next year. “We feel really good that everything will be coming together by this time next year,” he said. “In the meantime, the clock is still ticking.”


Sponsored links