updated 2:02 a.m. ET Jan. 4, 2007

NEW ORLEANS - Brady Quinn fell short again in the big game.

The surefire first-round draft pick couldn’t find a way to get Notre Dame the big win he’s been so desperate to deliver, failing for the third time this season against top 10 competition to complete more than 50 percent of his passes as Notre Dame lost 41-14 to LSU in the Sugar Bowl on Wednesday night.

His problems started on the game’s first play, when he underthrew open tight end John Carlson after LSU got some pressure on him. But unlike in the loss to Michigan, when Quinn barely had time to breathe before he had a defender in his face, against the Tigers he missed even when he had plenty of time. On Notre Dame’s second possession, he overthrew Jeff Samardzija when he was open along the left sideline.

Quinn also repeatedly had passes batted down along the line, and he didn’t get enough help from his receivers, such as when tight end Marcus Freeman dropped what would have been a first-down pass on Notre Dame’s first possession — and when a pass by Quinn bounced high off Rhema McKnight and was intercepted by LaRon Landry.

Quinn was just 15-of-35 passing for a season-low 148 yards. His other games of completing 50 percent or fewer came against Michigan, when he was 24-of-48, and against USC, when he was 22-of-45.

Coach Charlie Weis defended Quinn, though, saying part of the reason he struggled was because the game plan called for a lot of three-step drops to try to keep the Tigers off balance and it led to passes being batted down.

“I don’t think he was the sole problem out there,” Weis said. “It would be great if I could sit there and say, ’Yeah, he laid an egg,’ but that’s hardly the case.”

Quinn said the biggest problem was that the team couldn’t convert on third downs.

“We just weren’t productive,” he said.

Quinn threw only seven interceptions all season, but three came against the Wolverines and two against the Tigers. He nearly had another pass intercepted Wednesday night, but that was overturned when it was reviewed by officials.

Quinn did throw TD passes of 24 yards to David Grimes and 10 yards to Jeff Samardzija against the Tigers, but couldn’t make enough big plays to match the potent LSU offense — and the Irish defense had no chance of slowing the Tigers.

“We didn’t make enough plays, and really that’s what it comes to in offensive football,” Weis said.

The knock on Quinn early in his career was that he was a 50 percent passer who had his best performances in losses — primarily because the Irish had to pass so much to try to get back into games. That changed when Weis arrived last season and helped Quinn become a more complete passer.

College football Complete recaps of all 32 games

He led the Irish to two thrilling comeback victories this season over Michigan State and UCLA, but he couldn’t provide a victory when the Irish needed it most.

The Irish did manage to win twice against top 10 teams with Quinn at quarterback, beating No. 8 Michigan 28-20 in 2004 and No. 3 Michigan 17-10 in 2005. But in 2004 the Irish won despite Quinn, who threw for just 178 yards with three interceptions, and last year he threw for just 140 yards against a Wolverines squad that finished the season 7-5.

Weis said he’s not worried about the Sugar Bowl performance hurting Quinn’s draft position, saying he heard from some in the NFL that they were impressed by Quinn’s play against USC even though his numbers weren’t great.

“Because even though he was 50 percent in that game, if you really watch that game the kid played pretty well in the game,” Weis said. “I think they know this kid is good.”

Quinn, who won the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award given to the nation’s top senior quarterback, finishes his career with 36 Notre Dame records and will be remembered as the quarterback who helped restore the Irish back to respectability.

Slide show   Week in Sports Pictures Flying on the hardwood, racing on the rink, getting physical on the gridiron, and much more. more photos

Weis said he built a relationship with Quinn similar to the one he had in New England with Tom Brady, whom he describes as being like a son.

“For me to feel that strongly about Brady, that’s as high a testament as I can possibly give him,” Weis said.

But it was a disappointing end to what had been a somewhat disappointing season for Quinn. He came into the season as the Heisman Trophy favorite, following a record-setting junior season, and the Fighting Irish came into the season with the No. 2 ranking. But neither Quinn nor the Irish could live up to expectations, with Quinn finishing third for the Heisman and the Irish finishing out of the top 10.

That’s not the legacy Quinn was hoping for.

MORE FROM NOTRE DAME CENTRAL

Notre Dame Central Section Front

Inside the Irish blog: Latest news and analysis Predictions 101: Irish to bounce back, edge Pitt Inside the Irish: TE Rudolph out for the season Fighting Irish face tough test at No. 8 Pitt Inside the Irish: Theme of week is accountability ND's loss to Navy puts pressure on Weis again Notre Dame drops out of Top 25 Five things we learned: Red zone offense killed Irish Navy likely sinks Notre Dame's BCS bowl hopes Floyd's back, competition with Tate resumes Notre Dame Central Section Front   Add Notre Dame Central headlines to your news reader: