Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: FBI stalks gunman in Indiana hostage situation

Notre Dame doesn't deserve BCS bowl

Rout by USC proves Irish are most overhyped and don't deserve big payday

Weis, QuinnAP
Notre Dame head coach Charlie Weis and quarterback Brady Quinn watch from their sideline during their team's 44-24 loss to USC on Saturday.

To aid Notre Dame’s case even further, there isn’t much competition. Arkansas, which was No. 6 in the BCS, lost to LSU. West Virginia, which was No. 7, was upset by South Florida.

Yet let’s make believe Notre Dame isn’t Notre Dame. Let’s pretend the Irish are really Boise State or Rutgers or Wisconsin. With the Irish’s schedule, would the BCS bend over backwards to put such a 10-2 team into one of its lucrative slots considering the teams it beat and the way it lost to the teams it lost to?

The Irish will get in because they’re the Irish, not because they’re necessarily deserving.

Because of their schedule, it’s difficult to get a true read on Notre Dame. So much of the Irish’s appeal has to do with history, with Knute Rockne and waking up the echoes, and now with Weis and his large but charismatic presence on the sidelines. But how good are they?

“They’re a good football team,” said USC linebacker Keith Rivers after Saturday’s game. “They’re just as good as anyone else we’ve played.”

Said USC coach Pete Carroll of the Irish: “They’re a great team and they’re going to get theirs.”

I guess what he means is their cut of the BCS pie. As far as recognition as one of the premier programs in the country, the Irish still have a lot of work to do despite their record.

The Irish haven’t won a bowl game since they took a 24-21 decision over Texas A&M in the Cotton Bowl on January 1, 1994. In January of this year, they were pulverized by Ohio State in the Fiesta Bowl, 34-20.

Everyone in and around the Notre Dame program has been thrilled since Weis stepped on campus. And there was cause for buzz. He was a successful offensive coordinator with the New England Patriots, he has Super Bowl rings and he has a gritty, New Jersey pragmatism that endears him to football folk.

Slideshow
Image:
  The Week in Sports Pictures
A kayaker flips out, a racehorse eyes the Triple Crown and more.

more photos

But the disparity between USC and Notre Dame was significant Saturday night. It was even wider than the score indicated. The Trojans have recruited kids who are faster and more athletic. As tough and competitive as they are, the Irish don’t seem to have gained any ground on USC, Ohio State, Michigan and maybe others in the upper echelons of college football.

“This being the last game, playing in Southern California, five straight losses versus USC, it’s pretty disappointing,” defensive end Chris Frome said. “But we have one game left to prove ourselves as a team and to win a bowl game, which we haven’t done here in over a decade.”

But they keep getting invited. When you’re Notre Dame, maybe that’s all that matters.

Michael Ventre writes regularly for MSNBC.com and is a freelance writer in Los Angeles.


< Prev | 1 | 2

advertisement
Slideshow
Tyler Eifert , Nigel Bradham
  Notre Dame's 2011 season
Check out some of the best images from Notre Dame's 2011 season.

NBCSports.com

Timeline
Michigan v Notre Dame
Notre Dame 2011 schedule
See when all the big matchups will take place with Notre Dame's 2011 schedule.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Stanford v Notre Dame
  Meet the 2011 Irish
Take a look at some of the key contributors for Notre Dame this season
Slideshow
Discover Orange Bowl - Stanford v Virginia Tech
  2011 Notre Dame opponents
Take a look at some of the key players the Irish will face this season
Slideshow
Image: Discover Orange Bowl - West Virginia v Clemson
  College cheer
Check out some of the college football cheerleaders from across the country.

NBCSports.com