Skip navigation

Tragedy bruises baseball, but it will go on

Lidle's sad death should remind us how great an escape game can be

Tigers moment of silence
Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP
Detroit Tigers players observe a moment of the silence in memory of New York Yankees pitcher Cory Lidle, who died in a light plane crash Wednesday.
Slide show
Toronto Blue Jays v New York Yankees
  Remembering Lidle's career
A look back at the baseball career of Cory Lidle, who was killed in a small plane crash in New York City.
Video: Baseball reacts to tragedy
Today show
Pitcher's death shocks colleagues, fans
Oct. 12: The death of New York Yankees pitcher Cory Lidle left both teammates and rivals shocked. "Today" show anchor Meredith Vieira takes a look back at his life.

Slideshow
  Celebs in the stands
A look at some of the celebrities attending the 2009 MLB playoffs.

more photos

Video: Baseball from NBC Sports
New York fetes Yankees
Nov. 6: Yankees fans celebrated their team's 27th World Series victory Friday with a ticker tape parade in lower Manhattan. NBC's Brian Williams reports.

OPINION
By Mike Celizic
NBCSports.com contributor
updated 1:29 p.m. ET Oct. 12, 2006

Mike Celizic
NEW YORK - On Sunday, Cory Lidle was cleaning out his locker in Yankee Stadium, talking to teammates about flying his single-engine plane back to California and how much fun it would be.

Now he’s dead, his trip to California interrupted by a New York City apartment building not long after Lidle took off from Teterboro Airport in Bergen County, N.J. And the trite thing to say is, "Here we were getting all hot and bothered over whether Joe Torre should continue to manage the Yankees, and whether A-Rod should star in the Bronx or be sold to the highest bidder. This sure puts things into perspective."

The trouble with that statement is that whatever new perspective we gain from a tragedy like this evaporates like morning dew on a hot July morning the instant the game begins. The perspective we said we all gained when the games were canceled for a week after 9-11 lasted a couple of months before we were back to getting worked up over fun and games as if nothing had happened.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

That’s good and it’s healthy; it’s the way life is supposed to be. If we ever had true perspective on spectator sports, we wouldn’t bother with them because they are senseless frivolities. But we do bother with them for precisely that reason. They give us an escape, something harmless in which to invest our emotion, something to take our minds off the fragility of life.

When a tragedy like this occurs, it’s a shock because athletes aren’t supposed to die. That’s not part of the deal in the reality show that is spectator sports.

We know death happens elsewhere. It’s all around us, even if it usually takes place in hospitals instead of at home. But the death of a loved one from cancer or a neighbor in a car crash or a coworker in a rock-climbing accident doesn’t impress us the way that of an athlete does.

Athletes are the healthiest and fittest people among us, David Wells notwithstanding. They can do things physically that most of us can only dream of doing. They pull hammies and blow ACLs and tear rotator cuffs, but they don’t die. We like to talk about how young people in general and athletes in particular think of themselves as immortal, but we think of them that way, too.

So when an athlete dies, it’s like a slap in the face, an unwelcome reminder that even though athletes provide our entertainment, they also inhabit the real world in which bad things happen. The knee-jerk reaction at such moments is to say, "This puts things in perspective."

Rick Peterson is a pitching coach. He works for the Mets now, but once worked for the A’s when Lidle was on that staff. When word hit Shea Stadium that Lidle had died in the plane crash that was leading all the news broadcasts, Peterson was asked to talk to the media about it.

Peterson called Lidle’s death "horrific," adding, "It’s almost unbelievable.

"I think it just goes to show how insignificant some of the things that we think are significant really are. We’re about to play a baseball game, and how important is that really?

"This is not about life and death," he said of the sport to which he has dedicated his life and his talents. "It’s about entertainment."

After saying that, Peterson went back to the Mets clubhouse, where the players were waiting to see if the rain would life enough to get a game in. The game was later postponed, pushed back one day because of the weather.


Sponsored links