Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Mickelson a marvel at Pebble Beach, while Tiger tumbles

Duke rape case D.A. faces big questions

Many in legal community believe Nifong has little evidence to prosecute

Mike NifongAP
Durham County District Attorney Mike Nifong is the lead prosecutor in the rape allegations case against members of the Duke University lacrosse team.

The particulars of the Duke case were an explosive mix to begin with:

Black accuser, white athletes. Southern town, walled campus. Racial epithets. Protest rallies. National media.

Then Nifong lit the fuse.

In the weeks following the March 13 party where the alleged rape occurred, Nifong referred to the players in interviews as “hooligans” used to having “expensive lawyers” get them out of trouble. He denounced the “blue wall of silence” that had supposedly formed around the perpetrators and said DNA would reveal exactly who had committed the rape.

Even after DNA tests failed to establish a link between the players and the woman, Nifong took the case to the grand jury, which returned indictments against three men: Dave Evans, Collin Finnerty and Reade Seligmann.

Defense lawyers and bloggers have been picking apart his case ever since.

The alleged victim — a single mother who attends historically black North Carolina Central University — has told at least a dozen different versions of her story, by one defense lawyer’s count. Toxicology tests failed to show she was given a date-rape drug, as Nifong suggested in one article. Seligmann’s attorney says Nifong refused to look at cell phone logs, ATM video and taxicab receipts that supposedly prove his client couldn’t have committed the crime.

Nifong’s public statements “almost certainly” violated a state bar rule that forbids prosecutors from making comments outside court that have “a substantial likelihood of heightening public condemnation of the accused,” wrote K.C. Johnson on the Web log Durham-in-Wonderland.

“Few prosecutors in history have publicized their case and condemned potential defendants as egregiously as Nifong did,” wrote Johnson, a Brooklyn College constitutional history professor.

Suggesting that Nifong was grasping at anything to keep his case alive, critics noted that the second dancer at the party allegedly changed her story after the prosecutor personally intervened to have her bail reduced in an old embezzlement case. Others faulted the supervising detective’s 33-page report — which was handed over to the defense four months after the alleged attack, and which contradicts what the rape nurse and others remembered about the accuser’s early statements.

“There is almost no evidence that could be construed as corroborating the alleged victim’s accusations,” says Rob Warden, director of Northwestern University Law Center on Wrongful Convictions. “The prosecutor appears to have acted precipitously, without due consideration of evidence to the contrary — evidence that does not fit into their theory.”

Chastened by the attacks, and by a judge’s order to limit “extrajudicial” comments, the 56-year-old prosecutor has ceased giving interviews, though he has used court appearances to rebut his critics.

During a recent evidentiary hearing, Nifong shot to his feet when Evans’ attorney Brad Bannon suggested that the prosecution had “very little evidence” other than the accuser’s word.

“Your honor,” Nifong said, “I object to his characterization of my case.”

On his campaign Web site, alongside photos of his wife, son, and Australian shepherd, Tillie, Nifong defends himself against allegations of misconduct.

“I have never understood why any prosecutor would try to gain an advantage at trial by concealing evidence from the defendant,” he wrote, saying he began giving “open-file discovery” to all defense attorneys 20 years before the state legislature required it.

“And that is why I have never had a conviction overturned for violating a defendant’s right to discover the State’s case against him.”


advertisement
More news
Image: Pekingese Palacegarden Malachy trots in ring at the 135th Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show in New York
Reuters
Pekingese favored to be top dog

Robins: It’s the Year of the Dragon on the Lunar calendar, and this Chinese influence could extend to it also being the year of the Pekingese on the green carpet at the 136th Westminster Dog Show on Tuesday.

NY cable dispute blacks out Knicks, 4 NHL teams

NEW YORK (AP) - As the glow fades from the Giants' Super Bowl triumph, some New York sports fans are tuning in to basketball and hockey, with the Rangers in first place and the Knicks' overnight sensation, Jeremy Lin, sparking "Lin-sanity.''

Image:
AP
Six new breeds will join show at Westminster

Robins: This year, six new breeds will be making their debut on the green carpet for the Westminster Dog Show, which begins Monday.

Slide show
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

Slideshow
Boston Celtics v Indiana Pacers
  Who's hot on Twitter?
Check out which of your favorite athletes have the best pages and most followers!

NBCSports.com

Special feature
"American Woman: Fashioning A National Identity" Met Gala - Arrivals
When athletes and celebs get together
A look at the many links between sports and Hollywood stars.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: To match Special Report CAMPAIGN/ROMNEY-OLYMPICS
  Presidential candidates and sports
How do President Obama and his Republican rivals stack up when it comes to their sports backgrounds?