Skip navigation
Listen now:
NBC Sports: The Erik Kuselias Show

Clemens deserved to be traded to winner

Houston either needed to improve lineup or let legend go to contender

Image: Roger ClemensAP
In the last two years, the Astros haven't scored a run in 13 of Roger Clemens' 40 starts.

But when you consider what Clemens has given to the Astros and what he’s getting back, the team owes him — big time. He is the greatest right-hander and maybe the greatest pitcher of any ilk since at least 1930 and maybe beyond. Despite his age, he’s still getting big-league hitters out with absurd efficiency. Legends like Clemens get more because they deserve it. But what he deserves most of all — another chance to win — the Astros refused to give him.

Clemens’ name came up in trade talks before Monday’s deadline, and the Red Sox were one of the teams that tried to get a deal together for him. If the Astros were so inclined, they could have made it happen. They didn’t.

If McLane were serious about pursuing another trip to the playoffs, I’d understand. But the owner and general manager Tim Purpura could not bring in a bat to fortify the team’s anemic offense. Instead, according to reports, they shopped their two best pitchers — Clemens and Roy Oswalt — along with their closer, Brad Lidge, and even their one legitimate slugger — Morgan Ensberg.

Their target was supposed to be Miguel Tejada, the Orioles’ premier shortstop. Tejada would certainly have added offense to the ’Stros, but offering Oswalt or any of the other players named would have made the deal a wash. More hitting in return for less pitching. The object is to get better, not to tread water.

The Astros are half a team. They can pitch with the best of them, but they can’t hit. Lately, Lidge has been blowing saves, making their situation even worse.

Kansas City Royals v Boston Red Sox
Getty Images
The Week in Sports Pictures

The nation grieved for those hurt, killed and affected by the Boston Marathon bombings. After one of the suspects was caught on Friday — following a day-long lockdown and manhunt — sports returned to Boston over the weekend.

Yes, Clemens is the face of the franchise, the hometown hero who still awes the fans once every five days. But Houston fans would have to understand if the team had let him have one last shot at a ring. And the team could have reaped some prospects in return for him to help build a future that is better than the present. A win-win scenario was there for everyone.

McLane and Purpura couldn’t get it done. And Clemens is left to pitch in futility.

Mike Celizic writes regularly for MSNBC.com and is a freelance writer based in New York.


< Prev | 1 | 2

advertisement