Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Mickelson a marvel at Pebble Beach, while Tiger tumbles

Stern being King Solomon, not King David

Commissioner opts for measured, fair suspension over swift, severe justice

JIM LITKE
Jim Litke
AP columnist
After the “Malice at the Palace,” NBA chief David Stern called the boundary line separating fans from the players on the court “immutable” — something that can’t be changed. Fortunately for Antonio Davis, the commissioner’s sense of justice isn’t quite that rigid.

Stern’s approach to discipline has always been no-nonsense and sometimes downright imperial. He makes decisions swiftly and often unilaterally; hence the “King David” nickname occasionally applied behind his back.

He told the players what they can wear and fined Mavs owner Mark Cuban hard enough to make his wallet shudder. Until an arbitrator cut five months off the sentence, he was prepared to put Latrell Sprewell into storage for a year for leaving his fingerprints on his coach’s windpipe. He successfully put Ron Artest on ice for all but 10 games after the Palace episode.

But this is one instance where Stern recognized he was better off channeling King Solomon.

A five-game suspension will cost Davis upward of $630,000 in missed pay. It will cost an already anemic Knicks team one of its more able bodies. But it’s also a measured response that takes into account a very specific set of facts and still protects the principle Stern had to protect.

A large ballplayer wading into the stands to sort out trouble is going to end badly 99 times out of 100. Even when the ballplayer in question is calm enough to use the aisle. So give Davis credit for that, for keeping his head and his arms at his side. Intentions should matter.

The “he-said, she-said” dispute, meanwhile, between Davis’ wife, Kendra, and a Bulls fan that precipitated her husband’s visit to the seats won’t be settled anytime soon. The fan she got into it with didn’t appear to be drunk and Kendra apparently has mixed it up verbally with tougher competition before. When Davis played for Toronto, she got into a brief shouting match with Sprewell after Sprewell made a basket during Game 3 of a playoff series between the Knicks and Raptors a few years ago. And just like Sprewell, Bulls fan Michael Axelrod was unaware the woman he was dealing with was Davis’ wife.

But none of that was material in devising a fair punishment. When Davis saw a commotion in the crowd where his family was sitting, he didn’t care who was right so much as what might happen next. Just about anyone would have reacted the same way.

But that’s what the five-game suspension was meant to drive home. Davis’ foray into the stands turned out to be the exception to the rule, which probably owed to his character and generally good intentions. He’s one of the league’s best-liked, most-respected players, president of the union and enough of a standup guy to turn up at NBA headquarters Thursday to plead his case before Stern and his lieutenants in person.

FREE VIDEO
Fan speaks
Jan. 20: Chicago Bulls fan Michael Axelrod talks about the incident with Kendra Davis
Clearly, Davis got his point across. The statement released by Stu Jackson, the NBA’s vice president of basketball operations, said the league believed he was rushing to his wife’s aid, and took “those mitigating circumstances into account in setting the length of the suspension.”

In other words, 14 months after a few ballplayers put a lot of people in danger by fighting their way into the stands, the line is still — to use Stern’s carefully chosen word — “immutable.” No exceptions.

That Stern made this decision quickly might lead to some second-guessing. That he made it from the remove of a conference room in New York, with all the video evidence available, should ease most of those concerns.

From the film clips that were shown by midday Thursday, it appears security at the arena wasn’t only adequate, but close to resolving the problem until Davis waded in and racheted the intensity up a few notches. If they validated anything, it was Stern’s rock-solid belief that a player entering the stands under any circumstances will only make matters worse.

Slide show
Image: Snee, 8, son of New York Giants player Chris Snee and head coach Coughlin's grandson plays in the confetti after the New York Giants defeated the New England Patriots in the NFL Super Bowl XLVI football game in Indianapolis
  The Week in Sports Pictures
The Giants on top of the football world, getting ready for the London Olympics and more.

more photos

Louts in the seats and matchheads on the playing surface have been a volatile mix even before some genius thought up the idea of charging for tickets. The hefty prices and even heftier salaries have only made the antagonists feel more justified in heaping abuse on each other. Keeping them apart is more important than ever.

If Stern wants this ruling to have even more of a lasting effect, let him follow it up. Cracking down on fights that take place on the court — handing out the same five-game suspension Davis got instead of the standard one game for throwing a punch — is a good place to start.

Next, he can ask his owners to start thinking more carefully about the tickets handed out — or bought — by players. Stories abound about family members of visiting players being spat upon, harangued and intimidated. A skybox or something like the family sections set aside in baseball parks should be offered as an option.

It’s rough out there. And likely to get rougher. The last thing Stern can afford to do is give up any more ground.

© 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

advertisement
More news
Image: Kobe Bryant
AP
Kobe's shot lifts Lakers

Kobe Bryant hit a baseline jump shot with 4.2 seconds left and the Los Angeles Lakers wrapped up a six-game road trip by holding on to beat the Raptors 94-92 on Sunday, their eighth victory in nine meetings with Toronto

  ProBasketballTalk tweets

  1. Loading the latest posts…

Source: Twitter. For more, follow @basketballtalk.

Video: NBA from NBC Sports
Knicks, Lin still streaking
Knicks coach Mike D'Antoni and point guard Jeremy Lin discuss the team and Lin's recent success.

Slideshow
Washington Wizards v Charlotte Bobcats
  Get your cheer on
Check out some of the dancers from the NBA.

more photos

  Ask the NBA expert: Ira Winderman

Do you have a burning NBA question? Submit it now, and then check back for our reader mailbag.

Special feature
Image: LeBron James
Who will be MVP?
Interactive: Rank each player on a scale of 0 to 10 (10 = best player, 0 = barely worthy of consideration).

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image: Blake Griffin
  NBA All-Star starters
A look at the starting lineups for the East and West teams.

more photos